Radar Picked Up an Object the Controllers Didn’t Think Was a Plane
Two air traffic controllers tracked it for five or six minutes. An astronomical check found nothing unusual in the sky that night.
A US Air Force document records a sighting by two air traffic controllers at Kirtland on November 4, 1957. The officer who wrote the report suggested it might have been an aircraft that had lost its way, but the document does not identify the object.
At 10:45 p.m. on November 4, 1957, two air traffic controllers were in the control tower at Kirtland Air Force Base in New Mexico. One looked up to check the clouds and noticed a white light moving east at an altitude of about 1,500 feet. He called the base radar operator, which detects aircraft using radio waves, and asked for an identification.
Radar reported an unidentified object to the east that appeared on the screen just like a conventional aircraft. But the controllers didn’t think it looked like a conventional aircraft. One described it as “a car standing upright,” 15 to 18 feet tall. The object slowed to about 50 miles per hour, disappeared behind a fence in the well-lit Drumhead area, then resumed moving east at an altitude of a few hundred feet. One controller signaled from the tower with a green light, thinking it might be a helicopter in distress.
According to the witnesses, the object climbed “like a jet,” faster than any helicopter they knew, and disappeared. They tracked it for about five or six minutes, using binoculars for part of that time.
What Investigators Checked
Investigators examined the base radar and the weather. The sky was partly cloudy, and visibility was good. A University of New Mexico professor checked whether any unusual astronomical event had occurred that night and found none.
What the Report Says—and Doesn’t
The officer who prepared the report, a lieutenant colonel in charge of operations, wrote that the object might have been an unidentified aircraft that had confused Kirtland’s landing patterns with its own. He based this assessment on the witnesses’ reliability and skill, as well as the radar detection. The document, however, does not determine what the object was. It says the witnesses struggled to explain what they had seen and appeared bewildered.
Questions & answers
Who were the witnesses?
Two Kirtland air traffic controllers who had worked in the tower for eight and 16 years. The document describes them as reliable and skilled.
Did the report reach a conclusion?
No. The officer wrote that the object might have been an aircraft that had lost its way, but the document says it was never identified with certainty. The assessment rests on visual observations and radar returns alone.