Operations Officer: Witness Probably Saw a Mirage
A 1957 report described an egg-shaped object over New Mexico’s Highway 54 that remained in a witness’s view for three to four minutes.
A 1957 official Air Force report documents an electronics technician’s sighting of an egg-shaped object in New Mexico. The officer who signed the report concluded it was an optical illusion, but based his explanation on the speed the witness estimated, a point the investigation never fully examined.
Written on November 6, 1957, at Ent Air Force Base in Colorado, the report describes a sighting on Monday south of Orogrande, New Mexico, along Highway 54. It opens with a description of a pearl-colored, egg-shaped object above the Sacramento Mountains.
What the Witness Described
James Stokes was driving alone in a 1957 Mercury at about 70 miles per hour, on his way to El Paso, Texas. The radio began to fade, and the car slowed as if it had a battery problem. About six cars were stopped along the road, their occupants pointing at the sky. Stokes got out and saw the object to the northeast.
According to the report, the object descended from about 5,000 feet to between 1,500 and 2,500 feet, turned west toward the San Andres Mountains, and disappeared. About two minutes later, it made a similar maneuver, slightly south of its previous path. Stokes estimated its speed at between 1,500 and 2,000 miles per hour and said the sighting lasted three to four minutes. He reported no windows, no sound, no smoke trail, and no change in the object’s shape.
Stokes also reported a sudden rise in his body temperature, followed by sunburn. A medical examination found no evidence of a burn, and Stokes later withdrew the claim. The investigating officer also noted that Stokes seemed very sure of the details, though his account was not always consistent.
What the Investigation Found
A check with the briefing center at Holloman Air Force Base found no unidentified aircraft in the area at the time. The El Paso Weather Service concluded that conditions were not suitable for ball lightning, which investigators considered because of the object’s color.
The operations officer, a lieutenant colonel, wrote that Stokes had probably seen a mirage. Like the appearance of water on a hot road, a mirage could explain the sighting. The object didn’t match anything known, and the speed Stokes estimated was also incompatible with the sighting’s duration: an object moving that fast would not have remained in view for so long. In a flat, bright area, the officer wrote, mirages are not unusual.
The document notes that the descriptions are subjective and do not establish the object’s physical properties. The report does not determine exactly what Stokes saw. Investigators never located the two drivers who stopped near him, and no other witness reported a similar sighting. The report does not say what happened to the case afterward.