Reid Sought Special Restrictions on the Program. DIA Found No Basis
The request aimed to restrict access to program information beyond ordinary classification rules. In November 2009, the agency found no justification for doing so.
In a December 2010 internal memo, Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) Director Lt. Gen. Ronald L. Burgess recounted the fate of a program funded by Congress to study foreign aerospace threats. The memo said that in November 2009, the agency director and Deputy Secretary of Defense Lynn met with Senator Harry Reid and concluded that “the reports produced under the program were of limited value to DIA.”
Senate Funding, One Bidder
In 2008, $10 million was allocated to the program through a Department of Defense supplemental appropriations bill, at the urging of Reid, a Nevada Democrat, and Daniel Inouye, a Hawaii Democrat. The goal was to study threats from foreign airborne and space-based weapons, looking as far as 40 years ahead, and lay the groundwork for a center of expertise. After the agency issued a request for proposals, it received just one bid, from Bigelow Aerospace Advanced Space Studies.
26 Reports and a Secrecy Request
By June 2009, the company, working with academics and scientists, had produced 26 technical reports. All had reached DIA by September. One report, published in March 2010, examined propulsion for space travel using a method known as vacuum engineering. It was included as an example, but its contents are not described beyond its title. The 2010 budget allocated another $12 million to the program, which produced 12 more reports.
On June 24, 2009, Reid asked the Department of Defense to restrict access to information about the program beyond ordinary classification rules, using a mechanism that limits who is authorized to see it. The agency reviewed the request and concluded in November that there was not enough justification to classify the program and restrict access in this way.
Limited Value, and a Proposal to Transfer
That month, the agency director, Lynn, and Reid met. “At that time, we determined that the reports were of limited value to DIA,” Burgess wrote. He added that the reports might be valuable to other organizations and that, when the contract ended, the program could be transferred to