Avi Loeb: “They Could All Be Birds”
The release included 40 documents, including a 1952 CIA report. Loeb said the digital material wasn’t clear enough to identify the sightings.

Harvard researcher Avi Loeb was disappointed by the eighth batch of documents released by the Department of War on November 20. The digital material contains just three videos, which he said could all show birds. The radar data, he said, do not establish that the same object was tracked throughout the sighting.
Avi Loeb, a Harvard professor who studies unidentified anomalous phenomena, said he was disappointed by the eighth batch of documents the U.S. Department of War released on November 20. NewsNation reported his comments in an interview with Jesse Weber. The release contains just three videos, Loeb said, and “they could all be birds.”
The department is releasing the documents in batches. This batch includes a 1952 CIA report on flying saucers.
Three Videos, Three Unclear Sightings
The first video was recorded in 2020 by an infrared sensor mounted on a U.S. military platform in the Middle East. A bright spot enters the frame from the right and moves left. The second video, from 2023, is even shorter and shows just one spot.
In the third video, the sensor tracks several spots, repeatedly zooms in and out, and loses track of them for brief periods.
Radar Data May Point to More Than One Object
An analysis of 2023 radar data describes an object that may have been traveling at about 2,650 kilometers per hour at an altitude of roughly 17 to 21 kilometers, changing direction in flight. Loeb said the radar data do not clearly show that the same object was tracked throughout the sighting, and that the system may have detected several objects.
No evidence was presented that the object was unidentified. Birds or radar interference remain possible explanations.
Loeb illustrated the uncertainty with an example: “It’s not clear that it’s the same object. If you see a black car on the road behind you, and then a black car in front of you, it’s not necessarily the same car.”
Questions & answers
Why is Loeb disappointed with the release?
He said the digital material contains just three videos, and all of them could show birds. Without clear data, the sightings cannot be identified.
Was an unidentified object found?
No evidence was presented to support that. Loeb says the radar may have detected several objects rather than one, and that birds are also a possible explanation.