Professor Avi Loeb discusses the possibility that we have already received signals from extraterrestrial civilizations.
No comments yet. What did you see? Drop a timestamp (like 12:34) and everyone can jump straight to it.
Avi Loeb discusses whether intelligent life exists beyond Earth and argues that the question deserves scientific attention. He describes ‘Oumuamua, discovered in 2017, as an unusual interstellar object: its trajectory showed an extra push beyond the Sun’s gravity, and it appeared to emit little heat. Loeb raises the possibility of an artificial origin, but this remains a hypothesis rather than a confirmed finding. He also suggests looking for interstellar material in meteors and on the Moon.
The talk moves from nearby objects to possible signs of life and technology around distant worlds. Loeb discusses searching for artificial light and radiation associated with light sails, and outlines how laser-driven sails might propel small probes at high speeds. He then turns to the Fermi paradox: if other civilizations exist, why have we not found evidence of them? One possibility he raises is that many civilizations may have died out. He hopes that studying signs of past civilizations could offer lessons for humanity, while emphasizing the broader search for evidence beyond Earth.
0:00thank you very much Valerie in this talk I would like to discuss the possibility of intelligent life elsewhere assuming that we have one here some of us are still in doubt reading the newspapers every day a question are we alone is at least in my book the most fundamental question in science because one way or another it will change our perspective about our place in the universe and about our future as a civilization we would feel much more responsible to take good care of our planet and everything around it if we were alone and in fact just a few
0:47days ago the Nobel Prize was awarded to two people that discovered the first planet around a star like the Sun it was also given to the person that helped develop our model of the Big Bang the universe how it started and these are interrelated questions because we would like to know not only whether we are alone but when did life start in the universe how long it has been going well beyond a few million years that we heard about just before now we thought that we
1:34are at the center of the physical universe we had a picture where the earth was at the center and everything else was moving around it and then Copernicus helped us understand that we are not that central in fact the earth moves around the Sun and there are many other planets doing the same the many stars out there like the Sun and presumably they have planets as well but many of my colleagues still believe that we might be at the center of the living universe the biological universe that we might be unique or special and you might wonder
2:19how come they dare to think that given the history of science and the answer is that it's a very natural human tendency and I learned about it from my two young that's a picture from where when they were very young and they tended to think in their youth that the world centers on them and we as a civilization follow the same path it's quite natural to believe that you are at the center of the scene because you see everything around you but then as my daughters matured they realized that they are not at the center that in fact there are other kids on the street some with qualities that are
3:04better than they are they have and so the interesting question in our context is are we the smartest kid on the block not only whether we are alone but if we are not alone what else is out there and we will mature in that sense only once we find evidence for others on the cosmic string now looking at the sky I often tell my students looking at the sky makes you modest because you realize that you are just a small piece in the big scheme of things in fact when I read history books and I see Emperor's or kings that were boasting about conquering a small piece
3:51of land here on earth it looks ridiculous because in fact there are more grains that there are more planets like the earth in the observable volume of the universe than there are grains of sand on all beaches on earth so am emperor or a king that was boasting about conquering a piece of land here on earth resembles an ant hugging a single grain of sand on the landscape of a huge beach it's not very impressive the sky teaches us modesty and we better listen to that and be humble and not believe
4:36that we are special or unique and that things are centered on us and one way to figure it out is by collecting data on what we see on the sky or traveling there so another way to put it is as I mentioned before are we the smartest kid on the block and if you look on earth conditions allowed biology to develop the way we see it but if you look at cookbooks you find that you can start from the same ingredients mix them together in different ways and end up
5:22with different cakes and some cakes taste better than others depending on how you put ingredients together so it's quite conceivable that the same ingredients that we find here on earth were mixed in other ways on other planets and perhaps those cakes taste better in other words these beings are more intelligent than we are much more technologically mature by now and we can learn from them and so without having a prejudice we should simply search and what I'm really struck by is why this question and this motivation is not in the mainstream of
6:08astronomy because I can tell you from the experience ahead over the past year at least the public is extremely interested this is the most interesting question that the public cares about yet it's outside the mainstream of science even though we have the technology to address this question and that's something I don't fully understand because if the public is interested and the public is funding science then scientists should address this question why aren't they and of course the explanation is psychological there is the literature of science fiction there are reports that on unidentified flying objects that are not substantiated to
6:53the level of scrutiny of science and so scientists closed themselves in ivory towers and say this subject is not something I would like to be engaged in because we better be careful about making statements when there is so much public interest and much of the discussions that people have are not at the scientific level well my approach is quite different I say if the public cares about it and since it's such a fundamental question let's use the best tools we have the best ideas we have to make progress and address it and in fact science is not an occupation of the elite it's basically an activity that is
7:41driven by curiosity it's basically what all of us did as kids we were trying to figure out what the world is like without having a prejudice without being attached too much to our egos it's not about impressing other people it's not about getting more likes on Twitter science is about figuring out what reality is and you do that by having a dialogue with nature not a monologue in which you say what you think nature is you say there it's very unlikely to have life out there instead you go and explore it's a dialogue with nature you let later educate you and that's what we should do in this context as well and I don't see any difference between the pursuit of
8:26this question and the pursuit of a question like what is the nature of the dark matter how did the universe start what are black holes these are all scientific questions and we should apply the scientific methodology to address them especially questions that are of interest to the public that's my take on it and it takes me a while to try and convince my colleagues to bring it into the mainstream I haven't succeeded yet but I'm doing my best and so in exploring the answer to this question we should look up we tend to look down we tend to focus on what's going on here on earth but there is another dimension we live on a two-dimensional surface here on earth
9:12there is the third dimension and you better look into space and do something like archaeology by digging into space excavating space and looking for signatures of other civilizations that may have existed long time ago and may not be around anymore I call it space archaeology but we can find evidence for them just as we do when we excavate the ground and find evidence for ancient cultures that are not around anymore and the first place to start is in our backyard right because that's most accessible to us so what is our backyard our backyard is the solar system and the first the
10:01object that is closest to us in the solar system is the earth and in fact we can discover objects that arrive to us from outside the solar system how will we do that well these are called meteors meteor are objects that burn up in the atmosphere as they enter as they are on a collision course with with the earth and almost all of them originate in the solar system so they're not interesting that rocks that were left behind from the formation of the solar system but every now and then there may be an object that is not bound to the Sun that
10:46came into the solar system from outside that we could explore so in fact earlier this year I found this archive online of all the meteors that were discovered over the past 30 years and I suggested to an undergraduate student at Harvard that works with me to try and extrapolate the orbits of all these meteors that were reported and figure out if there is any one of them that may not be bound to the Sun if you go back in time you would figure out that it actually came from outside the solar system if it moves too fast and indeed we uncovered one that maybe
11:32interstellar in origin it was discovered back in 2014 and it had a speed of about 40 kilometers per second relative to the solar system when it entered the data comes from a system of sensors that belongs to the US government so the US government released the data on the speed of this object but without error bars the error bars were classified for obvious reasons and so currently we have the editor of the Astrophysical Journal letter identified a referee that has security clearance to look into the data
12:18and see whether indeed this particular object is interested in origins that's that's a very unusual situation we're waiting the results of that but in principle in there still are meteors that are big enough could leave a meteorite behind that would land on earth and that's our best bet for putting our hands on a piece of technology from outer space we just don't know of any such an example but it's a possible way of making progress the next place to look is on the moon so
13:03the moon is different from earth in the sense that it doesn't have an atmosphere so nothing burns up in the atmosphere in that sense it preserves everything that falls on its surface that's a good thing even small objects make a small crater and we see all these scars on the surface of the Moon and so you can think of the moon as a fishing net for everything collecting everything that is on a collision course with it moreover the moon doesn't have any geological activity so it doesn't mix up things that end up on its surface with the inside so in principle by looking on at the surface of the moon and examining
13:50the surface very carefully we could potentially find interstellar debris material that came on a journey from outside the solar system that landed on the moon and we could potentially search for signs of life in that material so if the was a piece of rock that came from the habitable zone around another star that ended up colliding with the moon over the past few billion years we might find the traces of that on the surface and potentially learn about those distant locations without the need to visit them we can just search on the
14:36surface of the Moon and indeed NASA announced its goal to go back to the moon by 2024 so this would be an interesting science project to excavate the the surface of the moon and search for interstellar material and one can identify that material by finding isotopes that do not have the same ratio as they do for the solar system so you can tell whether some material did not belong to the solar system to start with of course there are many objects that passed through the solar system and didn't collide with any planet like the earth
15:22or any moon and that material can be viewed in real time so the first report on an interstellar object an interstellar visitor was on October 19th 2017 about a couple of years ago and what was strange about it is it's just like having a guest for dinner you open the door and the guests come in and you notice that this guest is very strange nothing like any other guest you had before and you wonder what this guest might be but by the time you realize
16:09that it's so strange the guest left out into the dark street and you cannot watch it anymore so that was the experience with this one it was it discovered by a telescope in Hawaii pan-starrs and is called uma mwah which implies in Hawaiian scout a visitor from far away and it was very peculiar this one first as it tumbled the amount of light that was reflected amount of sunlight that was reflected from it varied by a factor of 10 or so and that's unusual we've never seen an
16:54object within the solar system with such an extreme geometry and that means that it's either cigar shaped with a length ten times longer than its width or pancake shaped and in fact a pancake shape is preferred by the most detailed analysis of the tumbling of this object and so it looks strange in that regard it was not expected the abundance of objects of this size was expected to be far smaller I wrote a paper a decade earlier saying that we would not see anything with pan-starrs it also was at rest relative to the
17:42local population of stars in the vicinity of the Sun so if you take the average of all the random motions of stars in the vicinity of the Sun there is the so-called local standard of rest and this object was at rest in that frame sort of like a Bowie sitting on the surface of the ocean and then a ship runs into it the ship being the solar system it's aside from its shape being unusual it also appeared to emit very little heat and so it's reflectivity was quite high relative to objects from the
18:29solar system and most importantly it deviated from an orbit that one expects just based on the sun's gravity so it's orbit exhibited an extra push and usually such a push is provided by a cometary outgassing when an icy object evaporates due to heating but by sunlight but there was no cometary tail to this object there was no dust no gas detected in its vicinity no water or carbon-based molecules and so a puzzle arose as to what gives
19:14it the extra propulsion and the only possibility that we thought about with a post-doc of mine will be our livers perhaps the push comes from sunlight that is reflected off a and if that's the case and if it's pancake shaped then maybe it's a solar sail maybe it's a sail that is being propelled by light reflecting off a we mentioned that in a paragraph in a scientific paper that was accepted for publication within a few days and I didn't regard this statement as unusual compared to other statements in papers that have written years before
20:00for example about the nature of the dark matter very often you put out a hypothesis with the hope that more more evidence we'll be able to test it rule it out or rule it in in this case the reactions were much more extreme and I still don't fully understand why the second interstellar object that was reported just about a month and a half ago is to I Borisov it was discovered by Gennady Borisov a Russian engineer amateur astronomer and this one looks just like a typical comet in the solar
20:48system so I was asked doesn't that convince you that Oh mwah mwah must have been natural in origin as well and my response is that if you walk down the street and you see a wordpress person and following that you see a lot of normal people that doesn't make the weird person normal in fact it's exactly the opposite way around because you realize how unusual the first object was but in principle one can estimate the abundance of objects like Oh mwah mwah that was estimated to be about hundred meters in size an object like 2i Borisov that is estimated to be about a kilometer in size this object brace off
21:35shows a cometary tail at a distance that is 10 times farther away from the Sun and you know the story of this one being natural and typical and who muah-muah being special resembles my first date with my wife you know I felt that she is special on that date and I have never met anyone like her since and so the fact that I met many other people later didn't change my opinion and the same applies to the first two interstellar objects that were reported now one can imagine interstellar object of this type that are trapped in the solar system
22:21if they pass close enough to Jupiter Jupiter gives them a gravitational kick that could bring them into a bound orbit around the Sun and one can calculate how many such objects should be trapped in the solar system so in principle the Sun and Jupiter trap objects in this way and after a while these objects are lost from the solar system because their orbit is unstable with some characteristic time so we estimated that about 6,000 such objects are expected to be in the solar system
23:06that have roughly the size of Omaha moi and identifying them would allow us to study those objects in much more detail than we were able to with Omaha so that's something to look for in the future and of course one can in principle study their composition by doing spectroscopy of any gases that come off them the easy way to identify them is by the highly inclined orbit that they have relative to the orbital plane of all the planets in the solar system most of the debris from the formation of the solar system is still orbiting in the same plane but these interstellar
23:53objects arrive to the solar system at some random angle and so you can easily pick them up by the inclination of their orbit and there are some highly inclined objects that were already identified that one can study more in the future and one can also estimate how frequently will such trapped objects collide with the earth for example and there should be quite a large number of them that collided with the earth and that is potentially interesting because it's possible that life was brought to Earth from outside the solar system it doesn't solve the question of the origin of life
24:38because you still have to produce it elsewhere but if life can be transferred between planetary systems potentially you don't need many sides in which life forms that will cede the rest of the galaxy now if we move farther out we could search for signatures of artificial light for example so you can ask the question how can you tell the difference between an object that produces its own light and an object that simply reflects sunlight well a simple way to do that is by seeing how the object dims as it goes away from us if it reflects sunlight the amount of
25:26light that is impinging on its surface goes down as one over the distance squared and then there is another factor of one over distance squared as to the brightness object of the object seen by us so altogether it deems like 1 over the distance to the fourth power whereas if it produces its own light the deeming will reflect just 1 over distance squad so by seeing how objects demas they move away from us you can potentially tell whether they are producing their own light or reflecting sunlight so an interesting calculation that we have done is how far can you see for example a city like Tokyo and the
26:14reason we chose Tokyo is because the numbers were out online about how much light it produces and turns out that you can see a city like Tokyo all the way to the edge of the solar system to the Kuiper belt so potentially with existing telescopes we can see an amount of light produced by an artificial source of light be the spacecraft or something else all the way out to the edge of the solar system with the Hubble Space Telescope for example as we move out of the solar system and here you can see a diagram of all the planets on the way out beyond Neptune which is still relatively
26:59close to us there is the heliopause that's where the solar wind the material that comes off the Sun that's where it meets the interstellar medium and that's roughly at a hundred times the earth-sun separation once you go to a hundred times farther than the earth is from the Sun you get to the point where the solar wind is stopped by the interstellar gas but that's not the end of the solar system that's roughly where the capability is the solar system continues to the so-called Oort cloud that is much farther out it's a hundred thousand times the Earth's Sun separation another factor of a hundred and at that point
27:49you are roughly halfway to the nearest star so the nearest star is about four light-years away it's Proxima Centauri and you can ask the question is there life around that star it turns out that this is a dwarf star about 12% of the mass of the Sun most of the stars in the Milky Way galaxy are much smaller than the Sun they would live much longer all the stars on nuclear reactors but these dwarf stars burn the nuclear fuel even though they have less fuel they burn it much more slowly than stars like the Sun and most of the stars are much smaller than the Sun like Proxima Centauri and they would
28:35live for up to a thousand times the lifetime of the Sun they would live for up to ten trillion years there will be still nuclear reactors in the sky that we can look at that we often call stars when the universe will age by another factor of a thousand and the Sun by then will die we will have to go somewhere else because it will be very cold here on if earth itself will exist and then we will need to move and the nearest star Proxima Centauri is a good place to think about now it turns out a couple of years ago there was a planet discovered around this star that is in the
29:20habitable zone of that star even though the star is fainter if you get close enough to the furnace you can keep yourself warm enough to have liquid water on the surface of the planet and potentially the chemistry of life as we know it this planet is called Proxima B and it's so close to the star it's about 20 times closer than the earth is from the Sun it's so close to the star that it has it faces the star with the same side at all times just like the moon faces us with the same side simply because the gravitational tide managed to keep the planet in that orientation
30:05at all times and so it has a permanent day side and a permanent night side this planet and my daughter when I told her about this planet when it was discovered my 14 years old daughter said that if we ever go there she would like to have two houses one in the permanent night side when she can sleep and the other one in the permanent Sunset Strip that separates the day side from the night side where she would like to have her vacations and she came across this idea when we visited Hawaii you can see a picture there so if you imagine yourself sitting on the beach of Proxima B there
30:52is a place where the real-estate value will be the highest where you can look at the sunset all day long throughout your life of course life is what we define to be life as we know it there could be other forms of life and one of the fundamental questions is how to identify it and whether indeed there is there are many different possible cakes that were baked on other planets compared to the one we find here on earth there is a warning sign from Mars that's a planet that had conditions that were suitable for life early on but then it lost its atmosphere
31:38because life as we know it requires liquid water and liquid water can exist only if there is external pressure otherwise solid ice goes straight into gas if there is no external pressure so in order to have liquid water in the chemistry of life as we know it you need an atmosphere and Mars lost its atmosphere because it's a smaller planet than the earth about a tenth of the mass so it lost its atmosphere and then there was no more liquid water possible on its surface and no life after that but there could have been life before that and potentially life was brought to Earth by
32:23Martian rocks we don't know perhaps we are all Martians but the fundamental question is does Proxima B have an atmosphere as to whether we would like to go there or whether there is life there and it's possible to figure it out without making the trip you can just look at the light curve the amount of light that you get from Proxima B as it moves around the star and the permanent day side is constantly illuminated it's hot whereas the permanent night side is called but if there is an atmosphere the temperature contrast between the hot side and the cold side will change
33:08because of winds because of heat redistribution and so just from the amount of light that you detect coming off the planet as it moves around you can tell the temperature contrast between the permanent day side in the permanent night side from the colors of the day side versus the night side you can tell what how different are the temperatures and so that's one way to tell if it has an atmosphere compared to a situation of bare rock because we know what the temperature contrast should be for bare rock and in a couple of years the James Webb Space Telescope will be
33:54launched into space and it has the potential to tell us whether Proxima B has an atmosphere or not so that would be interesting in addressing the question of whether travel agencies should advertise Proxima B as a good place to go to and other stars not far away where we see multiple planets some of which that are habitable for example the Trappist one system that as you can see has seven detected planets and three of them are in the habitable zone this one again is a dwarf star about 8% of the mass of the
34:43Sun and there are three planets potentially that could host life there and it's about ten times farther than Proxima Centauri so the journey will take ten ten times longer by the way if you want to make the journey with existing rockets it would take a hundred thousand years so if you wanted to get there now you should have boarded the spacecraft that left when the first humans left Africa hundred thousand years ago but that's with existing technology the hope is that we can develop as I will discuss in a few minutes better technologies that can
35:28propel us or pieces of equipment to much higher speeds we know that we would like to move into space because even though earth is our home and we can do the best we can to preserve it eventually there are all kinds of threats obviously in the short term climate change nuclear wars biological Wars chemical Wars but aside from self-inflicted wounds of the type that we are creating due to our advanced technologies there are external threats asteroid impacts the type of impact that
36:13killed the dinosaurs solar flares about 160 years ago there was an event called the Carrington event that impacted the earth and change the temperature of the atmosphere by a few degrees and if such a solar flare would have taken place today it would have cost the world economy trillions of dollars simply because we have all this technological infrastructure that was not there 160 years ago we should worry about these external threats they will not necessarily eliminate life but they are obviously a threat to our technologies and eventually of course the Sun will die so at that point we will have to
36:59move out in about a billion years from now nothing to lose sleep about immediately but eventually it's clear that we will need to venture into space and the most comfortable way to venture into space is by boarding a spacecraft that would feel just like sitting in this auditorium now what do we feel when we sit in this auditorium we feel that we are pulled towards the center of the earth with a gravitational acceleration of 1g that's the force of gravity that keeps us bound to the earth if you shut it off we would all fly into space okay so we have this force of gravity and
37:44Einstein in his theory of gravity educated us that if you bought a spacecraft that accelerates at 1g it would feel just like being on the surface of the earth there is no difference between gravity and acceleration that is artificially produced by an engine a rocket engine so imagine boarding a spacecraft that accelerates at 1g if you were to do that after one year you will reach the speed of light so it would feel very comfortable it would feel just like sitting in this room you sit in the room for a year you could in principle reach
38:30the speed of light the problem is you need an engine that will bring you to that speed and it's a huge amount of energy it's more fuel than we can imagine so it's not practical but it's possible and the interesting point is that if you continue to accelerate at 1 G during your lifetime you can actually traverse the entire universe and that's because of time dilation time is ticking more slowly in your frame relative to the rest of the universe so even though the rest of the universe ages by billions of years during that time since you are accelerating very close to the speed of light you can live through that journey
39:17that's an interesting possibility now how can we reach let's not be so ambitious but let's ask the question how can we reach the nearest star within our lifetime well one way to do that is to build a spacecraft that travels at a fraction of the speed of light let's say 1/5 of the speed of light then it will take it 2 decades to reach the nearest star how do you get to 1/5 of the speed of light while conventional rockets are limited by the exhaust speed they basically throw out material from their back end at some speed and they get boosted in
40:02the process but the problem with rockets is they carry their own fuel so they can't really reach a speed that far exceeds by more than one order of magnitude or so the speed the exhaust speed and that's why all the Rockets since Sputnik until now reach roughly the same speed of 30 kilometers per second we haven't made much progress in that regard so the way to circumvent this limitation is not to carry the fuel with the spacecraft and one way to do that is by imagining a light sail a sail that is being pushed
40:50by an external energy source that produces light that bounces off it and moves it forward this is not a new concept shortly after lasers were invented Robert Ford back in the early 60s imagined such a propulsion scheme but what can be done nowadays that was not possible in the early 60s is that one can imagine very powerful lasers that are pushing on a very lightweight sail made of special materials that has electronics attached to it and the guts of a cellphone nowadays can carry a navigation device communication device a
41:37camera and in principle you can launch all of these to a very high speed using this technology and the idea is very similar to a sailboat instead of a wind reflecting off the sails of a sailboat and giving it a push here light bounces off the sail and gives it a push and potentially you can accelerate a lightweight payload close to the speed of light this way and perhaps other civilizations have developed that so here is a brief history of my life I was born in a small village on a farm in Israel and I used to collect eggs every afternoon so I'm a
42:22farm boy haven't changed much since then and you can see a picture of me driving a tractor and I used to go to the hills reading philosophy books as a young kid and then one day an intrapreneur from Silicon Valley yuri milner showed up in my office and said would you be interested in leading a project to reach the nearest star within our lifetime breakthrough starshot didn't take me very long to say yes and we've been working on the technology since then a few years ago this is called star shot the idea is to imagine an array of laser
43:10beams that combine to make a very powerful beam and then releasing a sail above the atmosphere of the earth such that this combined beam gives it enough push to bring it to 1/5 of the speed of light within a few minutes and across that time it will move a distance that is about five times the distance to the moon at that point you stop the acceleration and then it moves on a ballistic trajectory towards the target and one can imagine launching such a sail once every day because they are not very expensive most of the expense is the infrastructure of the laser then it takes after those few minutes at the
43:56beginning bringing it to a fraction of the speed of light it would take about 20 years for the journey and eventually it will come close to Proxima B and take photographs of this planet and send them back to us now that's not the end of the story because it will take another four years for the signal to reach us and then eventually we might be able to see what's happening on this planet is it green does it have vegetation is it blue does it have oceans or maybe it's desert like and that is the concept that we came up with for going outside the solar
44:42system in a relatively short time and of course the many challenges you may worry about dust particles impinging on the spacecraft and of course if it moves at a fraction of the speed of light each collision is just like a tiny atomic explosion on the surface releases a lot of energy but we calculated that you don't need more than a coating of a few meters to protect the spacecraft against such particles and there are many challenges involving the technologies that are needed to make this happen we are only at the beginning of developing this technology and it involves the
45:27photon engine the sail and other challenges like the communication between the spacecraft and earth and so forth and we are just at the beginning of the process I'm being told that the policy issues will be even more challenging than the physics related technology issues because obviously one can use the same system for other purposes and we are trying to make as much progress as possible scientifically on these challenges such as the impact from dust or atoms in interstellar space at these very high speeds the plan is that in the first
46:13decade to demonstrate that in principle these challenges can be met and then dedicate the next decade to the construction of a prototype and hopefully in our lifetime to have a system if we are able to do that and one can imagine that there might be civilizations out there that had more time than we did and so they managed to master this technology so how can we find evidence for that by searching for signals leakage of radiation from those beams of light that are used to propel light sails so one
46:59can search for that especially for sysfore civilizations that try to transfer cargos between one planet and another planet when two planets line up along the our line of sight we might have a good chance of seeing that beam of light so we can forecast when to look and search for it and there are some flashes of light that are detected for example in the radio waves these are called fast radio bursts that are still an enigma Tec the popular view is that they originate from newly born neutron stars that are highly magnetized so neutron stars are stars roughly the size of a city about 10
47:44kilometers in size that have a mass of the Sun they have a density of nuclear matter and they are formed when a massive star collapses you can imagine after the form perhaps they have they possess very strong magnetic fields and can create these fast radio flashes that's the most popular view although we don't have evidence for that and it may be a mixed bag it may be that some fast radio bursts are natural in origin and others artificial in origin we have to find out but what's clear is that we as biological creatures are not well suited to travel through space in fact if we spend more than a year in space
48:29unprotected by the womb of the magnetic field of the earth that protects us from cosmic rays then a significant fraction of our brain cells will be damaged in that journey that is not discussed in science fiction movies about going to Mars establishing colonies and so forth there is a real health hazard and you can imagine that sending out technologies into space would be much more optimal you can imagine sending computers equipped with artificial intelligence and 3d printers such that they will produce whatever we want on the target planet out of the raw materials that exist out there so we can send especially if we are able to
49:14develop synthetic life in the laboratory ourselves then we will know the recipe for making life and we can design 3d printers that will make life wherever we want of the type that we want there is no need to and life in harm's way if we can produce it there artificially so it seems most natural for technological equipment to be sent out to space and we have sent Voyager 1 Voyager to New Horizons is making its way out of the solar system so you expect other civilizations to have done the same if they had long
49:59enough time and there might be some traffic out there that we haven't noticed because it's difficult to see these small objects with existing telescopes outside the solar system especially if they're very small if they're our star shot like objects they might be passing by and we haven't noticed and you can imagine even that civilizations travel on larger scales than galaxies because one thing we know about the universe is that it's not only expanding but the expansion of the universe is accelerating with time and so that means that all the galaxies is far away from us eventually will recede
50:44away from us at a speed greater than the speed of light we won't be able to learn about their whereabouts we won't be able to go and visit them beyond a certain time in the future because space itself is expanding at an accelerated speed and each and every one of those galaxies that are not bound to us will eventually reach the speed of light and we won't be able to figure out what happens there and get any signal from that galaxy beyond that time there is a horizon around us that we can observe and the galaxies will all exit from that horizon if the accelerated expansion continues so if you worry about the long-term future you might want to go to the place where most of the resources exist these
51:31are called clusters of galaxies but you might imagine civilizations migrating to where the party is or most of them find most resources that's one large cosmic scales and the fundamental question is why haven't we found evidence this question was posed by Enrico Fermi about 70 years ago after having lunch with his research group he basically said when they talked about extraterrestrial civilizations he said well if they're out there where is everybody why haven't we seen them and
52:17the most natural answer to this question is that possibly most of them are dead by now we know from our own experience that developing the advanced technologies we have brings in the risk of self-destruction so you can imagine that they have a short lifetime but that doesn't mean that you cannot find evidence for them because they left scars on their home planets in the form of burnt up surfaces or polluted atmospheres or photovoltaic cells that transfer light from the permanent day side to the
53:03permanent night side so one can do space archaeology and search for technological signatures of dead civilizations that's something we can do with existing telescopes that would be one way to figure out if there was somebody out there that is not around anymore look for mega structures around other stars for example and my hope is that this will be an important history lesson for us by finding dead civilizations that didn't behave properly they were not kind to each other or to
53:48their planet we will learn an important lesson to do better and avoid a similar fate so potentially we can find evidence for life by looking at fingerprints in the atmospheres of planets as they transit their host star one can search for oxygen but one can search also for industrial pollution this way and by the way the planet was outside the habitable zone if it was too cold to start with this might be a way of terraforming a planet making it habitable so it may not
54:34always be unintentional or or unintelligent to do sometimes you might want to warm up a planet by putting a blanket over it make keeping it warmer you can imagine looking for solar cells on Proxima be the permanent day side is constantly illuminated and in principle you can create electricity that would light up the permanent night side or transfer heat and it's possible to tell that without too much effort because if you watch the light curve of the planet once again you can tell the temperature difference between the day and night
The transcript is shortened here. Keep watching from this moment in the player.