An in-depth interview with astrophysicist Dr. Brian Keating. He discusses the possibility of extraterrestrial life, David Grusch's claims, and philosophy.
No comments yet. What did you see? Drop a timestamp (like 12:34) and everyone can jump straight to it.
Astrophysicist Brian Keating joins Julian Dorey for a wide-ranging conversation about dimensions, cosmology, science and faith. Using examples such as a two-dimensional world and holograms, Keating explains how extra dimensions might be imagined and discusses possible geometries of the universe. They turn to wormholes, relativity, time travel and the arrow of time, as well as scientists’ responsibility to explain their work to the public and the importance of admitting when science does not yet have an answer.
The conversation also considers life beyond Earth. Keating says that, on probability grounds, he thinks intelligent life must exist somewhere in the universe, while declining to specify what it might look like. He discusses David Grusch and the importance of whistleblower protections, and mentions 3I/ATLAS. Other topics include atheism, agnosticism, God, parenthood and purpose. Keating argues for recognizing uncertainty and seeking evidence rather than treating belief as knowledge.
0:10See what I got right here this time. >> Let's see what we got down in the hole. >> We usually keep it over there. >> You got any guesses? >> Tube. Uh that is a fragment of Elon's baby mama's uh umbilical cord. >> Yeah. No idea. No. There there there'd be too many baby mamas to choose from there. This is actually way more up your lane. >> Speaking of things that aren't umbilical, >> no. >> Atmospheric gas from Excellar. >> I'm going to This is painful. You're very far off. >> Ooh, an infinity cube. Oh, >> it's a tesseract. >> Can see me in there. Yeah, there I go. >> Tessarak. >> Wow. You got it FROM THE INFINITE. >> NO, MURF. DON'T leave him. >> That's right. It's like right out of the movie right there. Can people >> see that on camera? Right, thief? Can they see into it? Yeah. Matthew McConey.
0:57He's like banging around in there somewhere. Chris Williamson, I'm sure. >> I see him. There it goes. Wow. Nice. Mine to keep. No, >> not that one, but I am going to send you one for your studio. >> That would be nice. Yeah. Treasure that. That's right. >> Nice little center. >> We're going to go deep into this one. That is cool. From the fourth dimension. How thoughtful. I've never done a gift from the fourth dimension. >> How does this even work, by the way? Like the fourth dimension. I still don't understand that science. >> A real a real tesseract. [clears throat] >> Yeah. So the honest truth is that nobody not even the most brilliant person you know who ever lived in Mitioaku can understand and visualize exactly what a you know fourth dimension looks like and that's because you know we are doing something cool right now we live in three dimensions right can you see three dimensions can I see inside your body no
1:40>> no >> we have these magical telescopes in our head we have two telescopes in our head right they're refracting lensbased telescopes like your cameras over there >> they take images onto your retina what What dimensionality is your retina? I'm taking you back to math class. Is your is your retina on one dimensional? Two dimen is it a point? Is it a is it a plane? What? It's it's a sheet, right? It's a play in the back of your head. >> Actually, as you know, good old Andrew Huberman says, >> it's the only part of your brain that's not inside your skull, >> which is pretty crazy. Like, why would nature risk putting something outside of the skull's protection that's so valuable? It's your eye. It's because we need this more than any other sense, basically. I mean, you could get around without taste, and people do, >> but uh so we have two retinas, and they're each two-dimensional. From
2:26those, we get a stereo projection of what the world looks like. So, we're actually synthesizing a three-dimensional world from two two-dimensional worlds. Does that make sense? It's not it's not we're seeing into three. If I could see into three dimension, I'd see inside this this co, you know, this this, you know, I'd see the the vodka in my my uh Irish coffee over here or my my whis my whiskey. I should I should have gone that I'm, you know, part Irish. We can put some in there if you want. >> I know you got everything over here thanks to thanks to your crew here. I brought my whole crew with me, by the way. >> That's it. >> You're looking at them. >> All right. I like that. >> So, we can really only visualize things by making simple extrapolations from things that are simpler, like lower dimension things, right? >> Hey guys, three quick things. Number one, if you haven't subscribed, please
3:07subscribe. It's a huge, huge help. Number two, if you'd like to join my Patreon for early uncensored releases of the full episodes, you can join via the link in my description or in the pin comment below. And number three, if you'd like to join my clipping community for a chance to make content from the show and make money, you can join via the Discord link in my description below. So, the the easiest way to think about a tesseract is not to think about a testact at all. So, don't think about a tesseract. Don't think about the fourth dimension. Think about if you lived in two dimensions, like you're on a creature called a flat land. You're living in the flat land. That means you you you don't know about the perpendicular direction in three dimensions. You you you might be able to figure it out, but you can never see it. Your eyes don't work in that dimension. They only work along the axis of the
3:50plane, right? So, if you see something like what the f over here and you're in this dimension, you see this thing, it looks the same from every angle you perceive it, no matter how you go. So, you could be smart and you could figure out there are certain things that are symmetrical, right? They look the same in every direction. This thing is a straight line, right? Visualize that as a straight line. This looks very different as you go around it. Sometimes it looks like zero dimensional point. If I'm poking over here, if I'm going like this, I'll hold it up there. If you look along the axis, it's like a point, right? But if I look like this, it looks like a line. Then it's a point. That's this thing. It always looks the same if I'm in two dimensions looking along a line. And actually, my favorite book of all time, I give it away on my website, is called Flatland. Flatland is a is a science fiction story set in it's it
4:34comes from the late 1800s set in England, but it's not set in England. It's set in this fictitious world called Flatland. >> There's a two-dimensional dude and he gets visited by aliens from the third dimension. >> Wow. >> So, he's just sitting around one day and they have this whole society and societyy's pretty racist back then. So, you're judged by the number of sides that you have. So a triangle is a low educated man in the society because he has these three sides. A square is a little bit better. Uh a pentagon better until you get to a circle. The priests are circles. They're perfectly symmetrical. >> The men that are lowass worker drones, whatever. They're triangles. Cuz the more uh points you have, the uh the more high your status is. The fewer points
5:19you have, the more dangerous you are. Because in this world, if you have a point, you can poke somebody and kill them. So the if round person is not dangerous, they have huge high status. They're very powerful. But the lowest status people are women. Women are lines in this fictitious story called Flatland because Victoria. >> So this is like misogynist. >> So it's misogynist. It's racism. I mean the British had it all. >> Checking every box, man. >> The British had it all. Right. You know, thank God love him. >> And this is your favorite book. >> This my favorite. This is >> take you back to a nice pastime. my my racism. Uh yeah, that's right. Aspirational. No, it's it's called a romance of many dimensions. The reason is it helps you visualize the fourth dimension. It starts off with this guy in two dimensions. Then all of a sudden, he's visited by aliens, what he thinks are aliens from another dimension. A
6:05sphere, which is a three-dimensional object, comes to visit flatland. >> So now start to imagine what would you see if a sphere started coming into your universe if you could only see in two dimensions. Well, first you'd see like a tiny little point. Then it would come into a little bit of a circle. You could see it's a circle. Then a bigger circle. Then it would reach maximum diameter. Then it would start to shrink again. >> So you can start to visualize what the four what the third dimension is from the perspective of a second dimensional object like the square. It's trippy. >> He's the name of the author is a square like it's pretty funny. >> But the thing I want to get to is that they don't visualize things by what they would look like. You can't visualize. That's the problem. You try to visualize a test can't do it. What you can do is visualize the projection from a higher dimensional space. You've heard of
6:48holography. You've heard of this this notion that we exist and all the information a black hole can be contained on surface. That's called a holog. You ever get a credit card and it's got the eagle and it's like flapping it. That's a hologram. It looks threedimensional, but it's printed on a two dimensional thing. >> So like if if you're going to like IMAX 3D or something similar kind of >> that's not a hologram though. No, that's not. No, that's two different eyes stereographically projected with different colors or different polarizations. They fictitiously synthesize in your eye and that's sophisticated but it's not a hologram retains when I look at you I see color I see intensity and I see technically a little bit of polarization we talked about that last time >> um but we don't see the phase information of the light what actually tells me that your ear is farther away than your nose is the phase lag between
7:31the light coming from your ear coming to your from your nose they're different and my eyes can synthesize what that is a hologram is is taking that phase information called a conjugate 48 transform. That's what they do. They take it from a from a two-dimensional image. They synthesize it. It looks like a threedimensional. You see the eagle flapping its wings, right? You move it around, it looks like that's a hologram. Okay, that's that's that's different. But you can you can visualize these things from the projection. So now go back to again go back to being in flat land. >> If you're in flat land, when you see this pen this pen, you only see it either as a point or a line of different directions as you change your perspective around flatland, right? >> Um so it can go from that. Now imagine there's a light from above like in your studio here. It casts a shadow of this thing, right? It can look like one of
8:16two things. It can look like a line or it could look like a point, >> right? Depending on the angle. >> Exactly. Now take a um take a square. A square can look like a projection will look like a square or it will look like a line. Four different lines as you go around it. A sphere will always look like a circle if you project it light from above. The shadow of a sphere always looks like a two-dimensional circle. >> The shadow of a pen can look like a zero-dimensional object or a one-dimensional object. And a cube can also look like the shadow of a square. But no matter how you rotate it, you'll see the same thing. Imagine in four dimensions, the shadow of that tessoract is a three-dimensional cube. Imagine you're sitting here. >> How can you see a shadow in three dimensions? >> How do you see a shadow in two
9:01dimensions? It's the absence of light. So you're projecting beams of light, rays, you can laser shooting out this thing, >> right? But then you couldn't maybe I'm thinking this wrong, but hypothetically you could then argue that it's more dimensions. You'd be like, well actually it's eight. How do we know >> you? So an eighth dimensional the shadow of a of a fivedimensional object is a fourdimensional object. When you project something, you're always reducing it by one dimension. This is a line which is one dimensional. The projection of it's a point which is zero dimensional. Yes. >> A square, the projection of it's a is is a two-dimensional object. Projection of it to a one-dimensional object. Yes. the uh a cube projection of it is a two. So it's always going one minus the dimension that you start with. >> Right? But you understand what I'm saying. It looks the same in the end result when you're talking about the
9:40shadow. >> Well, the shadows, what we call the geometry of the shadow is what determines the dimensionality and the properties of the space. So the rulers, the angles, the protractors, those are how you measure geometry. And what you don't change is topology. So you we don't have any mugs here, but topology is not the Oh, there you go. You know, big telescope guy. How could I how could I >> careful? You're you're smudging it. >> Oh, okay. >> Cuz remember I write it on. >> It's so expensive. I know. I know you want I I'll put on the big big pop podcast guy. >> Yeah, we can use camera too for this, Steve. >> So, when you if you were to take this cling, it was once made of clay, right? You could smush it, you could make it into like a donut, right? But without patching it up or putting more holes in it, it will always have this one hole that you can't remove. >> So, this tells you the topology of the
10:24space. And there are a lot of people that study physics, including people that study extraterrestrials, that say that they're actually creatures that can travel not only from different dimensions. In other words, they can come from four. Remember this guy Grush keeps, you know, >> David Grush, I haven't had um >> very skeptical of a lot of the whistleblowers coming out. >> Uh I want to talk to you about that. Um because I think it's it's probably the most important story that nobody's interested in that is going around that people believe in things without evidence but then don't have evidence and don't believe in it. That that's bizarre. It's never happened in human history. Let's talk about it. But there's also a possibility of topological dimensional beings. Beings that can only exist in different topologies. In other words, different holes, different pinch points, different, you know, uh uh cones
11:09and stuff like that. So what's interesting about the dimensionality is that you cannot access a low dimension from a high dimension but you can you can access a high from a high dimension you can access to a low dimension but the reverse is not possible so that starts to set constraints on these aliens right if they're saying that these are interdimensional does that mean that they're auto does it automatically communicate to you that they're higher dimension or lower dimension >> to me it would automatically when I hear that communicate that they'd be higher dimension because it's like they could look in on us rather than up to us >> but there's nothing that says that you there's actually more you know dimensional space there's it's available for two-dimensional like if you think about evolution did evolution start with podcasters and you know start with killer whales >> definitely not >> the highest form of evolution you know
11:52two two white guys with a microphone right >> yeah I think I think we're cooked if that's the case >> so evolution goes from primitive to advanced right >> so the universe should be filled with primitive things and only a smattering like we see on earth we don't see there's only one species of humans you know how many different types of monkeys ate primates. The third there's there's literally thousands of different species. Bugs, there's billions of different types of species of bugs, probably sea creatures. Why is there only one homo sapien? Why is there only one creature like us that knows it has consciousness, exists in consciousness, can make forecast, can make tools, knows that it's going to die, knows how to live there's and knows that it may not be alone in the universe. There's only one species like that. But why, Julian? Why why are there 10 20 different type I'm trying to get a dog around the keing
12:37household, you And I want some big You don't have one yet? >> I don't have one. I have a killer cat. I have an attack cat. >> Yeah, we got to get you a dog. >> Yeah, I know. My You talk to my wife. She's >> We get you a nice like golden retriever instead of a German Shepherd. I love German Shepherds, but like you should start with >> I know. No, my uh my brother-in-law is a He's an ex military uh Marine Recon and he's got a he's got a serious Marine dog, you know. >> We got Mike Ritlin train a dog for you. >> Oh, yeah. >> That [ __ ] thing will probably eat >> Dog Whisper. Yeah. Yeah, I know. It's like Yeah. He's going to have my uh my my toddlers for snacks. >> Yes, Black Friday and the holiday season is here, which means if you're a business owner out there, you need business to be a booming. And if you got product to sell far and wide, there's nothing better to use than Shopify. This
13:22is the easiest place to set up your selling platform online where your customers get a great experience and get from point A to buying the product in the easiest way possible. Shopify helps you launch a store and start selling in a few simple steps. You don't need to be an e-commerce expert. Sidekick, Shopify's AI assistant, can help with business tasks along the way, from store setup to planning promotions. And their pre-built themes and AI site builder can make it easier to create a professional storefront. You want it to look good, and they're going to help with that. Shopify's mobile app also helps you manage key parts of your store from anywhere, including inventory, customer support, and most importantly, payments. And Spotify's checkout with shop pay is so good that it converts at a 36% higher rate than the competition. And obviously time is of the essence right now. If you
14:07go on and launch right now before Black Friday, you can take advantage of the extra online traffic. So don't wait. If you're ready to launch your business before Black Friday, go to shopify.com/julen link in my description below to start your free trial. Once again, for effect, go to shopify.com/julian today to hear your first >> um but [clears throat] uh but in reality there's many different species. That's a great mystery. It's one mystery that we have we have no explanation for. I'm talking to Richard Dawkins tonight. I'm hosting him at that. >> His evolutionary, you know, kind of imperative. It it is beautiful. It has incredible attractiveness. It's has parsimony. It's simple. It's AAM's razor. You can believe. But it can't explain the most diverse things like music. Why do you like music? What's the evolutionary advantage of music? Right.
14:53>> Why can't a dog and why can't a dog keep a beat? You know what I mean? Like seriously, like we can appreciate >> There's one dog that keeps a beat. His name is Snoop. Okay. >> It's actually the same age as me. And he's a grandfather, I think. It's amazing. Look at that. Okay. Come on. Come on. I got When you become a dad, you'll be you'll be doing dad jokes. You haven't become a dad since I saw you last time, have you? >> As far as I know. No. Couple close calls. >> Don't ever say that. The more famous you get, there's going to be people out there. >> Yeah. Anyway, >> uh so you'd expect low dimensionality to proliferate throughout the universe and yet your brain immediately goes because you're smart and and you think scientifically your brain goes to no it should be higher dimension but there's no reason for that. Now there's a lot more I want to tell you something very interesting about the universe for for a
15:34second. In [snorts] the universe it's possible that the universe can have different geometrical shapes to it. I want to explain what that means. On Earth, on this table, on this piece of paper, >> I can draw a triangle, right? That triangle has three angles. Duh. Right? The angles inside the triangle add up to 180°. Remember this from, you know, high school geometry. Okay? >> But on a sphere, here's a sphere, right? >> On a sphere, you can make a triangle that does the following. It starts at the North Pole. I hope this isn't like some huge podcast or It looks like a golf ball. >> It has my grandfather's thing. >> Oh, it does. Oh, that's beautiful. So at the very top, I've been to the South Pole. So I'll do it like this upside down. But imagine at the South Pole, Antarctica. I've been there twice. We should talk about that. There's crazy stuff going on down there. >> You can go from the South Pole to
16:20Kolkata, you know, or you know, Mumbai or something like that. And then you can go all the way around to San Diego. >> Hold it up just a little bit >> like this. Yep. >> So you can go from the South Pole up to the equator around say Mumbai. And then you go all the way across that equator till you get, you know, to New Mexico City, >> right? That triangle will have three 90deree angles. 3 * 90 is 270 degrees. That's called a non-ukidian triangle. Those triangles can have very different shapes than 180°. Only in the universe when the universe is flat do the angles add up to 180°. And I'll give you some examples. There's one other type of geometry. It's called hyperbolic or negative curvature. The easiest way to see that is a Pringles chip, which you
17:05know, hopefully maybe Amanda can get me some Pringles chips for lunch. Just kidding. I should have requested them earlier. She's so helpful. >> I mean, it's right downstairs. >> I know. I don't want to I don't want to I don't want her to miss on on on my boring cosmology lectures. >> That's right. >> She falls asleep over there, Brian. >> A Pringles chip. You draw a triangle. The triangles bow in like this. The angles bow in to less than 180°. Okay. So, three different geometries. You detect the geometry by the number of degrees inside of a triangle. Negative Pringles chips less than 180 degrees. Flat exactly 180 degrees. Spherical >> greater than 18. Okay. >> In the universe, let's say you take you make a triangle from Earth to the sun to uh Mars. Make that triangle. Okay. >> Wait, wait. Earth, >> Sun Mars. That's a triangle. Yeah.
17:50>> Okay. Yeah. Yeah. >> And you add up the angles inside that triangle. You get 180°. >> That's right. >> Now go uh Mars. Go to Alpha Centuri. the, you know, way the [ __ ] over way. Yeah. Four light years away. Yeah. >> And then you go from there, uh, back to the sun. >> Okay. So, you make a you make this really other huge triangle. >> You're saying that's not going to >> No, that does add up to 100. Okay. Now, here's the next one. You've heard of the Andromeda galaxy. It's the closest galaxy to the It's 3 million lightyears away from the Earth. >> Is that the one Kipping talks about >> where he's looking at exoplanets? >> He looks at exoplanets, but in our galaxy, he can't I don't think he can see them in other galaxies, but yeah, he he he does look at exoplanets and their moons. And some of the moons have moons, so they're going crazy. But Bart Sil doesn't believe that those moons exist.
18:32Okay, we got to talk about that. Uh, sorry. Throw Bart under the bus. Uh, that's kind of like he's my buddy now. We, you know, we we hung out on Piers Morgan. Oh, you did? >> Yeah. Yeah, I went on and debated him, right? >> Oh, you know what? I did see that. I did see that. That was [ __ ] hysterical. >> It was hilarious. Piers is like, "You're full of shit." You know, I I was like, I don't have to say anything. Pierce, please explain why >> why they wouldn't swear on a on a stack of Bibles. >> Listen, I think I think there's some part of the Moon story that is certainly questionable. I just don't think he's a great spokesman for >> No, he's not. And I know I heard you and Danny talking about how that's by design. Let's talk about that because that it's important. You know, I'm going on this Jubilee show hopefully in a couple months and and I'm going to be surrounded by flatearthers, moonlanding
19:15deniers, big bangers. >> No, I they are my favorite people, Julian. I get paid. I'm a public employee. I'm a I'm an employee of the state of college. Gavin Newsome ultimately is my boss. You know how lucky >> that's not a flex. >> That's not a flex. >> It's a flex for him, right? Um so I serve at the pleasure of you know Gavin Newsome, the regent of the University of California and the taxpayers of the and every scientist. I don't care who you are, you're supported by the government, right? My job is to give back. And that's partially why I come on podcast. I have my own podcast because you guys pay my my salary >> into the impossible podcast. Check it out on YouTube and Spotify and wherever you our podcast are are not sold, you know. I got a I got a model. >> You do have probably of anyone the best library of physicists and scientists on the internet.
20:00>> No, thanks. Yeah, I just have >> I mean it's like pretty unbelievable. >> 28th Nobel Prize winner to come on. He won the Nobel Prize last week for the discovery of high energy nutrinos from extra galactic and galactic. We're going to come back to that. >> We'll come back to that. But the thing I want to point out, I got to flex a little bit because you're my buddy. Um so I wrote him and he was on my show a couple years ago and and I wrote him. His name is Francis Hollen. Um, and I took classes with him. I I've known him very well for 30 years. And um, I just wrote him an email like uh, first of all, I got an email that night that he won from a guy who won the Nobel Prize in economics three years ago. We imbido and I become a little bit friendly. And so Wido, Guido, Guido, Wido, but it's pronounced Wido. He's Dutch. He won the Nobel Prize in economics. Okay. >> Okay. >> Then he writes to me, "Congratulations
20:44on your interview with Francis Holland." So, it's a Nobel Prize winner writing me, Brian Keading, non- Nobel Prize winner, loser of the Nobel Prize. Right. And then he writes me, "Great interview. I'm so I was so glad to see Francis. Congratulations. I hope you're doing well." Then I was like, "Oh, wow." He saw it. That's pretty cool. So, I wrote to Francis Halen who won it that day. I said, "Francis, I know you're too busy to respond. I just wanted to let you know, thinking of you. I'm so, you know, glad and blessed that you had the time to spend with me a couple years." He writes me back almost instantly. Brian, thank you so much for your kind message. Being on your podcast is making me more famous than the Nobel Prize. [snorts] >> Really? >> Yes. Wow. >> You know, he's a sweet guy. He's a man. She's 82 83. He's an incredible guy. I just wanted to flex that a little bit because the Gavin Newsome, it's got to
21:26be the antids consider it flexed, right? >> All right. So, we're back to this triangle. We were talking about Alpha Centauri and how it still makes 180°. >> And no matter how far you go out, you go out to Andromeda galaxy, you go out to the Whirlpool Galaxy, the Vert, any triangle of three points, a triangle is just three points. you. No triangles exist, Julian. I can't hand you a triangle. And an LLM cannot have a concept of what a triangle is. Only mathematically, but the human mind can, right? Cuz I can't give you something zero dimensional. Imagine here's a zero dimensional object. Julian, is that is that zero dimensional? That dot >> technically not. >> No. What is it? >> It's threedimensional. >> It's threedimension. That's right. Most people say two dimensional. >> No, you just made it. >> It's three. Yeah, there's ink. It's raised. It's billions of molecules there. It's it's a huge amount of stuff,
22:09right? >> Appears like >> it appears to our eye. Hey, that's the resolution of our eye and that so forth. >> Any triangle you make in the universe, no how matter how big it is, you can detect the geometry, the curvature of the universe out to that distance using this triangular method as long as you have objects that exist, but they're only, you know, they're mentally they're geometrically they're mathematically existing. Right. >> That's right. >> We've we've done those measurements. We know that the universe has zero curvature. It means that it's flat. That means no matter if you make the triangle out to the beginning of time when the first objects form, the earliest galaxies in the universe for example, or the microwave background that I study, any triangle you make will always have. But that's weird. I didn't tell you another fact though. How many different types of spheres are there? There's this
22:52sphere, there's a golf ball, there's a BB, there's uh the Earth, right? >> Technically, anything that is on some different angular whatever is going to be a different type of spir sphere down to the 0.00001%. 00001% difference from one infinite number of spheres, right? Okay. Pringles chips, horse saddles, um negative curvature spaces, same thing. There's an infinite number of those things because there's an infinite number what are called real numbers. Real numbers are numbers that have uh the properties that they they do. They're basically any number you count with plus rational plus irrational numbers. >> So, >> Terren Howard might argue with that. >> He definitely would. >> He might argue with that. >> Yeah, exactly. >> He might cook, too. >> He might. Yeah. I haven't I have not followed his culinary adventures. Uh the uh the weird thing is that so the universe could have one of three
23:36possibilities. Imagine I told you you can live in one of three different places. You could live in, you know, uh in in Hoboken, New Jersey. You could live on Earth somewhere. You could live in the universe somewhere. Which is which is more probable of all those things? Somewhere in the universe or specifically in Hoboken, New Jersey? Which is more probable? >> Somewhere in the universe. >> Somewhere in the universe. Right. So because there's an infinite number of places in the universe, there's only one Hobok in New Jersey. This is the center of the universe. >> This is the center. Yes. And I I love it. I actually grew up, you know, Hoboken. This is like Hobos are here. It's an awesome place. Congratulations. You You were You were at the forefront of this. This is going to be Austin, Texas. Describe Hoboken of the South. >> I tell everyone it's terrible here. Don't come. >> Do not come here. That's what I said
24:18about San Diego. Do not come. >> Oh, the weather's terrible. There was a cloud yesterday in San Diego. There's a cloud. >> Um, so anyway, you're absolutely right. There's an in when you have an infinite number of possibilities, that's much more likely. And and you just correctly identified there's an infinite number of spheres we could live in. There's infinite number of pringles. But why do we live in the only there's only one flat universe. There's only one why why is that? Why >> are you saying that symbolically as in like how it looks versus how it actually is? Because it has to be 3D. >> It No, no. Well, or we live in three dimensions. But three dimensions can have three one of three different curvatures. Negative curvature like a Pringle ship, positive curvature like a sphere or flat. But there's an infinite number of negative curvature surfaces that you correctly identify. There's an
24:59infinite number of spheres that we could live. But zero curvature flat universe, not flat zero dimension, threedimensional flat universe. There's only one. And we live in that one. That's a great mystery. >> Threedimensional flat universe. >> So we live in a threedimensional spatial dimensions, one time dimension, and then we have different possibilities for the curvature of light beams as they travel in space. Here's another thing that would happen. If we live in a flat universe, these all go back to Uklid, you know, 2,300 years ago, right? Uklid said you have two parallel lines, you shoot two lasers parallel to each other and they'll never come together. Okay, that's >> perfectly parallel. >> They're perfectly par Yeah, we everything in math is is perfect, right? >> But if you're on a sphere and you shoot two laser beams, they're perfectly parallel at the equator, right? They'll
25:45come together at the North Pole or the South Pole, right? If you if they travel only along the lines of what are called the the lines of of longitude, right? M. So they'll travel along the surface. They'll converge. So they don't stay parallel. They started off parallel at the equator. Two guys shooting laser and then they went up. Yeah. And on a Pringles chip, what do you think happens in a Pringle chip universe? Horse saddle universe. You shoot two lasers parallel initially. What happens to them? >> I mean, they're not going to be parallel pretty quickly. >> That's right. But what will they do? Will they converge, diverge, or stay parallel? >> They're not going to stay parallel. They're going to diverge, right? >> Yes. Exact 100%. Those are the only three options. But there's an infinite number of ways they could go away from each other, right? They could start off really slowly and diverge. They could
26:27diverge really quickly. >> But if they diverge, are we on now, now I'm getting real meta here, but are we on some sort of plane to where they cross over at some point and then reconvert? >> Exactly. And that would mean that we could go out in a direction. You could come to San Diego in in our universe. >> San Diego >> and you'd eventually come back around and you come back to Hoboken. >> Yeah. >> Right. But we don't see that. >> There's an infinite number of ways they could converge. There's an infinite number of ways they could diverge. There's only one way they can stay parallel and that's the universe we live in. Why? Why do we live in the universe that has this property that light beams do these crazy things and oh by the way it happens to be fit for life and it happens to be fit for life that can develop consciousness and that consciousness can contemplate the very parallelism that defines the geometry of
27:11the universe. >> That's what physicists are trying to do. You wonder what what is Eric Weinstein trying to do? What what is uh uh Mitchukaku trying to do? What is Brian Green trying to do? What is Terren Howard trying to do? They're all theorists. Okay, I'm an experimentalist. Very different thing. I I don't work on theories of what the universe could be like. I could give a crap about what the different types of the universe could be. I want to know what it is. And I want to collect data to actually falsify or verify the different properties that we have access to because it's very freaking hard to do what I do. It takes millions of dollars. It takes hundreds of people. It takes decades of time. And I'm blessed to be in this position where I have millions of of dollars from my uh you know funding agencies and my collaborators. I've got the most brilliant leaders and collaborators in the world. And I've had 10 years worth
27:57of time with these brilliant collaborators in this money and our job is to put out data into the universe so you and the audience and everybody can benefit from it. Again, my job is the thing I hate about most scientists is that they don't as much as I have problems and beefs with Mioaku. >> You got some beef with the Kaku. Well, I've given him a war. Yes, I have a beef with him. He was on Diary of a CEO where I've been on before. And he said and spouted out some of the most ridiculous and quite frankly unscientific claims >> like what? >> Okay, so he said um he was talking about um first of all, I want to I want to say something to you. It's Kabad. It's not Chabad. Kabad. Can you say that with me? >> Kabad. >> Kabad. Kab. That's like the guys out in Brooklyn, right?
28:42>> It's that guys in Brooklyn. Yeah. Yeah. What's that? But I just tunnels. The tunnel. The tunnel is one one thing, right? >> I'm just saying. I don't know what the [ __ ] going on. >> We can go there. But um but but here's the deal. Kabat, not habit or chabat. >> I never said chabet. Why are you saying >> you and Danny said chab? No. Come on. No no no. That's a Danny Jones mistake. Danny Jones. Hold on a minute. Don't Don't you put that on me for us. >> I got it. I got I want >> Don't do that. >> But the e here's something the Habad rabb >> That is totally something Danny Jones do. I'm going to I'm going to throw him right under the bus right now. I love Danny. But yeah, but uh but but uh it's it's Kabad. Okay. Has nothing to do with it. Here's my beef. Okay. The beef with with the [ __ ] >> with with Oh, don't do that. >> I was stuck. I got stuck. Okay. Glitched. I'm an old man. Come on.
29:26>> He's afraid of me now. >> Um I know. I know. You You costed him, you know. >> I didn't Hold on. Hold on. No, I actually got to So I had him on >> three and a half years ago in my parents house. >> Eric Wininstein. Yeah. >> Yeah. This is like at the height of when I was like sick as a dog with with eosinaphilic asthma. So I was about 45 lbs lighter and he comes on, we do a really fun podcast. It was one of my favorites I ever did. Nicest guy ever. And then this past December, so like 3 years later roughly, I'm walking down 6th Avenue in New York from my doctor's office and I'm coming up on Bryant Park where the Bank of America building is and I see Mitchioaku and his wife, it was like really cold out, walking like towards the Bank of America building. I'm like, "Oh [ __ ] I've been trying. I'd love to get him back on the show."
30:11So, I like kind of beline it for him and I hold out my hand to shake his hand. I go, "Dr. Kaku, how you doing?" And he looks at me with with total fear in his eyes. His wife begins to reach for what I can only surmise is pepper spray. And then like I'm like, >> "Smart lady, >> you remember me? You you were on my podcast a few years back." And he goes, >> "No, I don't think so." >> Actually, I don't. >> And I was like, "Well, I'd love to get you back on at some point." He's like, "Okay, you reach out to team." And I was like, "All right, thanks." And I'm pretty sure they thought I was there to mug them. I was not. Would love to have you back on. But let's get back to your beef you had with. >> So the beef is that scientists have an obligation to share what we do with the public because the public pays our salary. Imagine you worked at Dunkin Donuts. Okay. You're working there. You know, you got a step up. Uh you got a
30:56promotion. You're working behind the I don't know. They're making the donuts. Remember the commercial in the in the in the Well, you're you're too young, but I remember commercial in the '8s. Okay. There's a guy with the mustache. He was making the donuts and they were trying to say, "Oh, you know, the donuts are fresh all the time." And so you see this guy and he wakes up in the morning and his wife's like, "Where are you going? It's 4:30 in the morning. Time to make the donuts." Then he goes out, he goes to work, you know, time to make the donuts. And then eventually he meets himself in a parallel universe and they both the both of these copies of this of this clerk say to each other, "Time to make the donuts." Okay. Anyway, it's it's a classic for people of a certain Gen Xers. Okay? You zoomers don't know what I'm talking about. One of the most annoying parts about shopping for fashion online is when you have way too
31:35many options and you just endlessly scroll without making a decision. It's like they put too much sensory overload in your face and nothing ever happens. And this is why Revolve Man is so awesome as a tool. They create a field that feels curated, not chaotic. It's edited in a way that makes sense. Everything's styled so you can see how it works. It's not just a product on a white background. It's the whole outfit. And that's another thing. When you get the full look instead of just one piece, you get help knowing what goes with what, so you're not just guessing. The two-day shipping is free. And if you order a couple options for a trip or an event, it's genuinely stress-free to be able to send back what you don't end up using. When you go on their site, you find one piece you like, and the site will then show you similar options or the full look, so the whole thing starts to come together all in one place. You
The transcript is shortened here. Keep watching from this moment in the player.