Astronauts Saw Objects in Space. NASA Tried to Identify Them
A man asked what had passed by astronauts. NASA replied that some of the sightings were water droplets.
A man asked what had passed by astronauts. NASA replied that some of the sightings were water droplets.
A man asked NASA for information about objects seen by astronauts. The agency said some were debris from launch vehicles or spacecraft, while others were water droplets. No unidentified objects were seen on lunar missions.
A 1998 case file of NASA Office of Legislative Affairs correspondence handling constituent UFO inquiries forwarded by members of Congress and the White House. It bundles Headquarters Action Tracking System (HATS) routing sheets, incoming constituent letters and White House emails, and NASA's draft and signed reply letters (most signed by Acting Associate Administrator for Legislative Affairs Edward Heffernan). The replies consistently state that NASA has no program for investigating UFOs, withholds no sighting information, and that no branch of government is currently investigating UFOs or alien life. Enclosed reference materials include James E. Oberg's debunking article on "astronaut UFOs" and the NASA Fact Sheet "The US Government and Unidentified Flying Objects" (FS-1997-01-017-HQ).
A constituent (forwarded by Sen. Grassley) reports watching the NASA channel's nighttime Earth view and seeing a light rise vertically, the shuttle camera track and zoom in on it, the light make an apparent 90-degree turn, after which NASA allegedly cut the external camera feed to a Houston view.
A 12-year-old self-described UFO researcher in Portland, Maine (forwarded by Sen. Snowe) submits a list of 15 alleged UFO sightings and abductions worldwide, requests FOIA release of Roswell crash documents, and asserts aliens and craft are held at Wright-Patterson AFB 'Hangar 18' and that an agency called 'MJ-12' exists.
"NASA has no program for investigating UFOs and has not withheld information on sightings."
Speaker: Edward Heffernan, NASA
Why it matters: Core official position repeated across the correspondence.
Page 4
"There are no recently released Mariner photographs. We assume [redacted] is referring to the images taken from our Mars Global Surveyor (MGS). NASA does not tamper with images received from MGS."
Speaker: Edward Heffernan, NASA
Why it matters: NASA response to a constituent doubting the authenticity of released Mars images.
Page 41
"Of the total of 12,618 sightings reported to Project Blue Book, 701 remain "unidentified.""
Speaker: NASA Fact Sheet FS-1997-01-017-HQ
Why it matters: Official summary statistic for the terminated USAF UFO program.
Page 66
"Will you push for open hearings or are you stonewalled as well by MJ-12? Certainly on your appointment as President you were briefed on the existence of UFOs."
Speaker: Constituent email to President Clinton
Why it matters: Constituent references the December 1997 Steven Greer/CSETI briefing claim and MJ-12 in a direct appeal to the President.
Page 54
"Today the search for extraterrestrials is conducted through The Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence Institute (SETI Institute) in Mountain View, CA."
Speaker: NASA draft reply
Why it matters: Explains that the congressionally terminated NASA HRMS/SETI program was effectively replaced by the private SETI Institute.
Page 43
Edward Heffernan
Acting Associate Administrator for Legislative Affairs (signer of replies) · NASA · Page 4
Charles E. Grassley
U.S. Senator forwarding constituent inquiry · U.S. Senate (Iowa) · Page 3
Olympia J. Snowe
U.S. Senator forwarding constituent inquiries · U.S. Senate (Maine) · Page 2
Bart Gordon
U.S. Representative forwarding constituent inquiry · U.S. House of Representatives (Tennessee, 6th District) · Page 60
Mary D. Kerwin
Deputy Associate Administrator for Legislative Affairs · NASA · Page 32
Lawrence E. Medway
Director, Congressional Inquiries Division · NASA · Page 42
Helen Rothman
Director, Congressional Inquiries Division, Office of Legislative Affairs · NASA · Page 79
Lynn W. Heninger
Legislative Affairs staff (drafted/initialed replies) · NASA · Page 41
Ruth Netting
Action officer assigned to draft replies (S/Ruth Netting) · NASA · Page 4
Sue J. Smith
Director, Office of Agency Liaison (referred White House casework in bulk) · The White House · Page 52
Steven Greer
International Director of CSETI, cited by constituents urging hearings · Center for the Study of Extraterrestrial Intelligence (CSETI) · Page 53
James E. Oberg
Author of enclosed reference article debunking astronaut UFO claims · aerospace writer / Space World magazine · Page 6
Robert F. Allnutt
Former NASA Assistant Administrator for Legislative Affairs (quoted in enclosure) · NASA · Page 31
Constituent names, addresses, and HATS abstract keywords throughout the correspondence
Likely reason: (b)(6) personal privacy of private citizens
Keywords field on HATS tracking sheet for L/1998-00407
Likely reason: (b)(5) deliberative process privilege
Keywords field on HATS tracking sheet for L/1998-00729
Likely reason: (b)(6) personal privacy
Primary document is 1998 NASA Office of Legislative Affairs constituent-correspondence casework (HATS routing sheets + incoming letters/emails + draft and signed replies); the bulk of the page count is two enclosed reference items — James Oberg's astronaut-UFO debunking article (heavily OCR-degraded, pages 6-31) and the NASA UFO Fact Sheet (pages 65-67, 80-81). Astronaut sighting 'cases' (McDivitt/Gemini-4, Apollo 11/12, Skylab, X-15, etc.) appear only inside those enclosures and are presented as debunked, not as the document's own claims. Tracking IDs to cross-link other records: L/1998-00407, L/1998-00415, L/1998-00470, L/1998-00494, L/1998-00729, A98-00789/A/1998-00310, A98-01199/A/1998-00461, LA98-00106.
According to NASA, some were debris from launch vehicles or spacecraft, while others were water droplets.
NASA wrote that it had no program to investigate unidentified objects and had not withheld information about sightings.
Dale Myers
Associate Administrator for Manned Space Flight (quoted in enclosure) · NASA · Page 20
Stonington, Maine, USA
Page 42
Portland, Maine, USA
Page 79
Ventura, California, USA
Page 53
Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA
Page 72
Groom Lake / Area 51, Nevada, USA
Page 33
Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Ohio, USA
Page 65
Mountain View, California, USA
Page 43
Roswell, New Mexico, USA
Page 66
Mars Global Surveyor (MGS)
spacecraft · Page 41
Gemini-4
spacecraft · Page 6
Apollo 11
spacecraft · Page 17
Apollo 12
spacecraft · Page 20
Skylab
spacecraft · Page 25
X-15
aircraft · Page 28
A man from Maine wanted to know about objects astronauts had seen in space. Senator Chuck Grassley forwarded his request to NASA, the US space agency. The agency responded in a letter from 1998.
The response confirmed that astronauts had seen many objects during spaceflight. But “object” didn’t always mean something large or mysterious. According to NASA, some of the sightings were water droplets; others were debris from launch vehicles or spacecraft. And on lunar missions, the agency wrote, astronauts saw no objects they couldn’t identify.
NASA wrote that some objects were later identified with the help of photographs or records from NORAD, a system that tracks objects in space. According to the letter, the records and photographs helped identify some of the things seen near spacecraft.
The explanations included debris from launch vehicles or spacecraft. In other cases, what looked like an object was a water droplet. These are specific examples of the kinds of objects that were identified, even though the letter doesn’t say what any particular astronaut saw. A sighting in space that sounds unusual may turn out to be material left over from a mission or a tiny droplet.
NASA said no unidentified objects had been seen on lunar missions. The letter described no chase or dramatic encounter; it simply summarized what the agency knew about astronauts’ sightings.
The letter also noted that the US Air Force had received reports of such objects in the past and investigated them for years, but had stopped. NASA wrote that it had no program to investigate unidentified objects and had not withheld information about sightings.
The letter doesn’t specify what every object was or what an astronaut saw in any particular case. It lists several explanations, including debris from launch vehicles or spacecraft and water droplets, and reports that no unidentified objects were seen on lunar missions.
In space, even a tiny droplet can look like a mystery.