Two of the Three People Authorized in the Annex Are Senators
In 2009, Reid asked to move parts of a study of space threats into a more restricted program. The letter does not detail the findings.
In a June 2009 letter, Senator Harry Reid asked to move parts of a program studying space threats into a highly restricted-access category. The annex lists the people authorized to see the material, including the letter’s sender. The document does not say what, if anything, the study found.
The annex lists the people authorized to see certain parts of the program: Deputy Secretary of Defense William Lynn III, the letter’s recipient; Senator Harry Reid, who sent it; and Senator Daniel Inouye of Hawaii.
In September 2008, the Senate directed the Defense Intelligence Agency (DIA) to examine advanced foreign threats in space over a period of at least 40 years. Reid said the study had already produced “some very sensitive and unconventional findings” and asked to move parts of it into a restricted Special Access Program (SAP). SAPs impose controls beyond ordinary classification: only people with specific authorization can see a program’s details. Reid said standard procedures for handling classified information would not suffice, nor would the usual SAP protocols.
What Had to Remain Secret
The letter identified four areas that needed to remain secret: the methods used to detect, acquire, study, and engineer the technologies; the allocation of personnel; the technologies’ application and engineering; and industry partnerships. Reid argued that a company identified as taking part in the program might stop working with the government. He also said experts should not be identified by name, because that would expose them to unnecessary scrutiny.
What the Document Doesn’t Say
The letter does not detail the study’s results. It contains claims, a request, and names, but not a single concrete finding.
According to a note from AARO, the office that now investigates unidentified anomalous phenomena, AATIP—the name Reid used—was another name for the AAWSAP program, which the DIA funded from 2008 to 2012, not a separate program. The 2010 contractor list names three people but does not identify their companies. The annex notes that some portions are exempt from disclosure under the Freedom of Information Act, yet the document was released.
Questions & answers
What is an SAP?
A Special Access Program with restrictions beyond ordinary classification, in which only a closed list of authorized people knows the details.
Does the document prove that unusual findings were made?
No. The document contains claims and a request for secrecy, but no results.