סרט תיעודי על טענת האסטרונאוט גורדון קופר, חבר בצוות מרקורי 7, שעב"ם נחת בבסיס חיל האוויר אדוארדס ב-1957. צוות צילום תיעד את האירוע.
עדיין אין תגובות. מה ראיתם? אפשר לכתוב שעה בסרטון (למשל 12:34) כדי שכולם יקפצו לשם.
הסרט התיעודי בוחן את סיפורו של האסטרונאוט גורדון קופר, שלפיו עב״ם נחת בבסיס חיל האוויר אדוארדס ב-1957, צוות צילום תיעד אותו והסרט נשלח לוושינגטון. קופר סיפר שהעצם נחת על קרקעית אגם יבש, בעוד שבטפסים שמילאו שני מפעילי המצלמה באותו יום תואר עצם שהתרחק עד שנעלם. הם לא כתבו שראו נחיתה.
תיק חיל האוויר מסווג את העצם כבלון, אך דוח הבסיס עצמו קבע שהבלון ששוחרר באותו בוקר לא יכול היה להיות העצם. הסרט עובר על צילומי מצלמת המעקב, ניתוח חיל האוויר, עדויות הצלמים שנמסרו מאוחר יותר ורישום מ-1975 המתעד משלוח של סרט אדוארדס לוושינגטון. הוא גם בוחן את גרסאותיו המשתנות של קופר ואת חומרי ההקלטה שלו שפורסמו ב-2026.
המסמכים תומכים בכך שסרט צולם ונשלח בנפרד מהתיק, אך אינם מבהירים מה נראה בתשלילים או אם קופר ראה אותם. היכן הם נמצאים כיום ומה בדיוק תיעדו נותר לא ידוע. קטעים המסומנים כשחזור הם המחשות שנוצרו בבינה מלאכותית ובתלת־ממד, לא תיעוד של האירוע.
0:00An astronaut said a flying saucer landed at Edwards Air Force Base in 1957. He said a camera crew filmed it. And he said Washington took the film. His name was Gordon Cooper, one of the Mercury Seven. That spring he was a test pilot at Edwards. Years later, he said it came in over the crew, put down three landing gear and sat on the dry lake bed while the men walked toward it, filming. He said he held the film up to his office window before a courier flew it to Washington. "And I don't know," he said, "whether anyone has ever seen it since." The Air Force file on that morning runs a hundred and six pages. I've read every one.
0:45There is no landing in it. Gordon Cooper's name isn't in it. Its conclusion is two words. "Was balloon." But in that same file the base's own report says the balloon "could not have been" the object. And a shipping form shows a roll of film from that morning going where Cooper said it went. To Washington. And the file still holds these. Real frames, from an Air Force tracking camera shot a few minutes after eight that same morning. Something is sitting in the crosshairs. So what did that camera actually catch? And how did an astronaut come to tell it so differently from the two men who shot it? Start with those two men, because they are the only people the file puts there.
1:34It is Thursday, the second of May, at seven fifty-five in the morning. The base report gives the weather: scattered clouds at 6,000 feet light wind, visibility thirty miles. Two civilian camera operators are driving a pickup truck south across the Edwards range on their way to a tracking station called Askania number four. One is thirty-two years old and the other twenty-nine and the file lists both of them the same way. "Instrument mechanic and operator." Their names are blacked out. They turn east. The passenger looks up through the windshield and calls the driver's attention to something. The driver wrote it down that same day. "It was hanging stationary almost overhead.
2:19I stopped the vehicle and got out to look at it." Then they drove on to the station, because that's where the camera was. An Askania is a tracking camera for flight tests. This one had an eighty-four inch lens and a fifteen power scope for aiming it. That morning it was under a cover, and it wasn't loaded. "By the time we got the camera uncovered loaded and ready," the driver wrote, "ten minutes had elapsed." By then the thing was heading east. At times, the base report says it "appeared to stand still and change shape or pulsate." They fired the camera by hand. The second man put it at about forty frames. Then they followed it through the scope until, in the driver's words
3:04"It just finally got too far away to see." The whole thing start to finish, lasted about twenty-five minutes. The same day, each man filled out the Air Force's questionnaire. The driver put the size at a hundred and fifty feet across. Color: "a bright metallic color." Sound: none. The form has a box where the witness draws what he saw. This is the driver's first sketch labeled "At first." A rounded shape, seen from below. There's a second sketch beside it. We'll come back to that one. And here is something to carry with you. Neither man wrote the word "landed." Not that day and not on any page that followed. In their account it drifts east until it's gone.
3:52They drove in, and the film went to the lab. By their account, that was the last they saw of it. Now the same morning, the way Gordon Cooper told it. In the spring of 1957 Cooper was thirty years old and he had just finished test pilot school at Edwards. NASA's biography has him assigned there as an aeronautical engineer and test pilot. Two years later he was picked for Project Mercury. Six years later he was alone in orbit twenty-two times around the Earth, the last American ever launched into orbit alone. When the capsule's automatic systems failed near the end, he flew it down by hand. As witnesses go, it is hard to do better.
4:45That's his voice, from the Faith Seven capsule. Here is what he said on television in 1996 by a transcript printed that year. A camera crew was out on the dry lake bed filming, when a saucer flew over their heads. In other tellings the crew is his own, out there to film a new landing system. It "put down three little landing gear and landed right on the dry lake bed." The men picked up their cameras and started toward it, filming as they went. When they got close, it lifted, pulled the gear back in and left at a great rate of speed. "And so they came into my office," Cooper said, "and told me what had happened." He said he reported it up the chain, and was told to send the film to Washington.
5:31In a documentary in 2,003 he added a courier already waiting at his office when the film came back from the lab. And one more thing. There was no time to run it through a projector. "I had a chance to hold it up to the window and look at it. It was certainly good film." In his memoir, in 2,000, he said what was on it. "A classic saucer, shiny silver and smooth." Then the plane left for Washington. So set the two side by side. In the cameramen's forms, it drifts away. In the astronaut's story, it lands. And both of them are describing the same roll of film. That roll had a number. Seven, three seven four five, three four three.
6:18Hold on to it. So. Two cameramen, one roll of film, and an astronaut who says it shows a landing. The first people to look into it were at Edwards itself. The base had its report out within two weeks. It went over the name of Lieutenant Colonel Raymond P. Klein, acting deputy chief of staff for operations. And the first thing the base did was the obvious thing: it asked about balloons. Four weather stations around that desert were queried. Palmdale. George Air Force Base. Mojave. China Lake. Had any of them released a balloon around that time? The report says, "Reply in each case was negative." Then Edwards checked its own.
7:05And there was one. The base weather station had released an instrument balloon at seven forty that morning. Fifteen minutes before the two men looked up. That could have been the end of it. But this kind of balloon is tracked as it climbs, and the base had the track. Ten minutes after release it was at 13,000 feet. Ten minutes after that, almost 23,000, and well downrange. Somebody drew its path by hand across a map of the lake bed. The map is still in the file. The base laid that path against the spot where the two men stood, and wrote this. "The weather balloon released at Edwards could not have been the unidentified object reported." And on the next line. "Probable cause of sighting is unknown."
7:53An Air Force base checked its own balloon against its own tracking data, and ruled it out. That report was mailed to an air defense unit in Colorado Springs. It did not go to the office that handled UFO reports for the whole Air Force, in Dayton, Ohio. Dayton found out the way everybody else did. From a newspaper. On May ninth a wire service moved the story. Two civilian technicians at Edwards had photographed an unidentified object with special tracking equipment. Unofficial sources said it looked circular and glinted in the morning sun. And intelligence officers at Edwards which the wire called "a hush-hush Air Force test center," would say almost nothing.
8:38The Los Angeles Times got one officer to say a little more. It could have been a weather balloon, he said. And then: "This desert air does crazy things." The papers put the sighting on Friday, May third. So did Gordon Cooper, later. The Air Force paperwork says Thursday the second, and I'm going with the paperwork. In Dayton, the men who ran Project Blue Book read that story along with everyone else. On May seventeenth they wired Edwards. The message is in the file, in capitals. "This center has no knowledge or receipt of report or photographs." And then: "Matter now of some concern." The paperwork reached Dayton on May twenty-third.
9:23The next morning a sergeant there phoned the Edwards weather detachment and spoke to a Major Wininger. By the sergeant's account the major said the alleged UFO "was obviously this balloon." Then Dayton took the base's report apart. The two men had said the object was a hundred and fifty feet across. On the photographs, after enlargement it was "scarcely larger than the width of the cross hairs." One witness had compared its size to a basketball. Hold a basketball in front of your eyes, Dayton wrote back. Anything that big at 5,000 feet would be almost half a mile wide. And then a line about the men themselves. "One observer has given strong indications that he
10:08is a believer in the so-called flying saucers." That part is fair. On his form, asked whether he had ever seen anything like it before one of them answered yes. In January of 1950, he wrote a large disk hung over a house west of the town of Rosamond for twenty minutes. Dayton's summary of the case says a study of the photographs showed the object "to be the size of a match head." It also says "This case is considered to have been improperly handled." And the card at the front of the file got its two words. The men said a hundred and fifty feet. The photographs said a match head. So I went and looked at the photographs.
10:55The National Archives scan keeps them in two folders. One is labeled forty-one photos, and the other twenty-two. Here is what a frame from an Askania looks like. The camera sits on a mount that measures exactly where it is pointing. Every frame records that. Scales along the edges give the angles, and there's a crosshair dead center. The whole point of the instrument is to put an aircraft or a missile on that cross and hold it there so engineers can work out afterward where it was, second by second. Like this fighter, on a NACA tracking camera in 1955. The base report says these were shot beginning about seven minutes past eight at two frames a second.
11:40And there it is. On the cross, or just off it. A small pale oval in gray grain. It gets a little rounder, then a little flatter, from one frame to the next. That is all there is on any of them. An analyst in Dayton measured that oval frame by frame and plotted it. Across some fifty frames the image shrinks to about a third of its size. Whatever it was, it was getting farther away. On that much, the file and the cameramen agree. No disk. No dome. No landing gear. Forty-one photographs, and not one of them shows the ground. So Dayton was right about the prints. On these, it's a speck.
12:26But look at how the base described what it was sending. Enlargements from negative one and enlargements from negative two, every other frame. And then the last two items on the list. Negative one, and negative two, "forwarded under separate cover." They are not in the file. What's in the file is paper, prints made from film that went somewhere else. And in the summer of 1957, the Air Force still knew exactly where. People asked for those pictures at the time. A flying saucer club in Los Angeles wrote to the Air Force eight days after the sighting. The answer came a month later. The object had been "conclusively identified as a balloon," and there would be no prints.
13:12A man in Denver who asked that summer was told the Air Force "does not have sufficient personnel" to pull case files for people who "wish to write for profit on the subject." Inside the building, the tone was different. A memo dated June fourth from Captain George Gregory of the Blue Book office, says this. "The original film is in repository with the UFO files." And any decision to release it the memo goes on, "must come from higher levels." So the film existed. It had a shelf. And a decision about it was sitting somewhere above a captain. Blue Book shut down in 1969. The year before that a physicist from Arizona gave the two cameramen their names back.
13:57In front of Congress. July twenty-ninth, 1968. The House Committee on Science and Astronautics holds a one-day symposium on unidentified flying objects. One of the scientists it invites is James McDonald an atmospheric physicist from the University of Arizona. In his written statement, case forty-one is Edwards. McDonald had done something the Air Force never did in public. He found the men. He gives their names: James D. Bittick and John R. Gettys Junior. He had interviewed both, and their range director, Frank Baker. What they told him has things the 1957 forms don't. They called Baker and asked whether any other camera station was manned
14:45because two cameras on one object give you its distance. Nobody else was on duty. Baker told them to fire manually. And the object. When they first saw it, Bittick told him it was no more than 500 yards off. Both men described "a golden color." It looked, they said "somewhat like an inverted plate with a dome on top," with "square holes or panels around the dome," though Gettys remembered the holes as round. Then the film. They drove in, and it was processed right away. All three men told McDonald the shots taken at closer range "were very sharp." The dome and the openings they said, "showed in the photos."
15:30And then this sentence. "The photos were shortly taken by Base military authorities and were never seen again by the men." Later that day they were told they had photographed a weather balloon distorted by the desert air. Neither of them accepted it. They saw weather balloons released there all the time McDonald wrote, "and knew what balloons looked like." The file says a match head. The men who took the pictures say you could see the dome. Now, eleven years is a long time, and a story can grow a dome. So go back to the questionnaire from May second 1957, and the box where the driver drew what he saw. You've seen the first sketch. This is the second. It's labeled "fifteen minutes later." A long, flat disk.
16:18With a bump on top. He drew that the same day. Before the newspapers, and long before Congress. A later researcher, Michael Swords, working from filmed interviews with both men adds that three officers questioned them separately and that Bittick finally asked his boss, "Do I have to put up with this crap?" But notice what is still missing. Eleven years on, in a statement written for Congress, nobody has said it landed. And nobody has said the name Cooper. So by 1968 there are two versions. The file's speck, and the cameramen's dome. The landing belongs to a third man, and it hasn't been told yet. In 1982 the space writer James Oberg reached John
17:06Gettys and told him what Gordon Cooper had been saying. Oberg printed the reply. "I am amazed that Gordon Cooper said the object landed. As far as I know, he never even saw it. His story sounds kind of funny to me." That quote reaches us only through Oberg, a committed skeptic, so weigh it that way. According to him Gettys had not even known that a future astronaut was on the base that morning. What can be checked is the paper. NASA's biography puts Cooper at Edwards in 1957 in flight test engineering. He was there. But the Blue Book file names the officers who touched this case at Edwards, in Colorado Springs, in Dayton. It never names Gordon Cooper.
17:52He isn't the officer who took the report, and he isn't the one who shipped the film. The man who took the pictures didn't know the astronaut was part of the story. So where does the landing come from? Follow it by the year. For twenty years after that morning, there is nothing. Cooper flies Mercury, then Gemini. In 1970 he leaves NASA and the Air Force. If he said a word in public about Edwards before 1977 I haven't found it. It starts in 1977, with a taped interview quoted by Oberg. It runs two sentences. There was "the case of one that landed out on the dry lake bed right out from a number of camera crews we had
18:37who filmed it." And the film "was sent forward to the safekeeping somewhere in Washington never to be seen again." There is no landing gear yet, no office, and no window. And the crews are "camera crews we had," not yet his own. A year later, in 1978 the story usually goes that Gordon Cooper testified to the United Nations. The U.N. record says something else. On November twenty-seventh the delegate from Grenada read out a letter, because Cooper, he said "was not able to come." The letter says he believes extraterrestrial vehicles are visiting this planet. It also says, "I have not yet had the privilege of flying a UFO nor of meeting the crew of one." It does not mention Edwards.
19:27Then Omni magazine, in the spring of 1980. "If any UFO information is being suppressed, it's certainly not in the U.S. Air Force, because I was at a high enough level to know about it." Then television, in 1996, and now there are three landing gear. The crew walks up to it. The men come to his office. The memoir follows in 2,000. By a reviewer's summary the book adds a phone call to the Pentagon that is passed from a captain to a colonel to a general an order to make no prints, and a locked courier pouch. And in the documentary, in 2,003, the courier is already waiting. He holds the film to the window.
20:12Every time it's told, there is one more piece. And in that same interview he is asked whether he ever kept in touch with anyone about the film. His answer: "There is no way, within the military or within the government of keeping track of something that is classified unless you're directly involved in it. And I was not." And listen to the grammar, in every version. "Camera crews we had who filmed it." "They came into my office and told me." "They picked up their cameras." Gordon Cooper never once says, I saw it land. In his own telling he is always in the office. There are two ways to hear all of this. One is a memory that grew for forty years around a morning he only heard about.
20:59The other is a man who really did have those negatives on his desk for an hour and who spent the rest of his life retelling what two cameramen told him a little better each time. The file can't tell you which. There is one more recording of Gordon Cooper to hear. The Pentagon released it in twenty twenty-six. In May and June of twenty twenty-six the Defense Department posted two batches of historical UFO material. Three of the files are Gordon Cooper. Two are audio from Faith Seven. Cooper in orbit, May 1963, early in the flight.
21:47"John's fireflies," because John Glenn saw them first. Small bright particles, drifting off behind the capsule. He reports them the way he reports everything else on that flight, evenly. NASA's explanation is frost breaking off the spacecraft. The third file is older. November 1962, six months before his flight. Walter Cronkite asks whether he still thinks there might be something to the flying object stories. Cooper says a large number of well qualified people have seen things with no logical explanation. Maybe every one of them does have an explanation, he says. But there are thousands of planets out there that might have a livable atmosphere.
22:42"I would hate to rule out the possibility." That is five years after Edwards. And fifteen years before he says anything about Edwards in public. Cronkite follows up. Does he expect to see anything out there himself, on his flight? Cooper says no. Mercury, he says, is "only getting out a hundred miles or so." For years, stories went around that astronauts had radioed UFO sightings from orbit. The best known has Cooper himself reporting a glowing green object over Australia. Asked in Omni about allegations like that, he knocked them down. He said tapes of astronaut communications had been "deliberately falsified," with UFO material edited in.
23:27To his knowledge only one astronaut had ever seen anything in space that might have been a UFO and it wasn't him. So look at the shape of it. In orbit, where nobody could have checked him, Gordon Cooper claimed nothing. On the ground, at a base with a file, he claimed a landing. That is not how a man behaves who simply likes a good story. Which leaves the balloon. Take the Air Force's answer seriously for a minute because it is stronger than two words on a card. The balloon was real. It went up at seven forty from the base weather station a few miles west of the two men, and the wind aloft was blowing west to east. Toward them.
24:12The base report gives the station's coordinates the men's coordinates, and the balloon's position every ten minutes. So you can do the arithmetic the file never quite shows you. I did. At eight o'clock, by the base's own table that balloon was about three miles from where the pickup stopped. And about four miles up. Remember the ten minutes it took to uncover the camera? In those ten minutes the balloon climbed more than 9,000 feet. And Dayton's numbers on the photographs hold up. To leave a speck that size from nine to twelve miles out an object has to be five to seven feet across. The balloon, at launch, was six or seven. There's a problem inside the cameramen's own account, too.
24:59In 1968, Bittick put the first shot at about a mile. But in 1957, the driver wrote that when the film was taken the object was "forty to fifty miles away." So their story moved over the years as well. So here is my reading. Most likely, what sits in those crosshairs is the seven forty balloon. I think that is the fair way to read the forty-one prints. Now here is what that doesn't cover. It doesn't explain why the base, holding the same tracking table wrote "could not have been." That June Dayton told the saucer club in Los Angeles that the balloon had passed the observers "at almost the precise time bearings, elevations and speed reported by them." One balloon
25:45one table, and two Air Force offices reading it in opposite directions. Somebody later penciled a note in the margin of that page. It's faint. It appears to say that the balloon's actual track "almost precisely matches" what the men reported. Nobody signed it. It doesn't explain two men who watched those balloons go up all the time and who drew a disk with a bump on top the same afternoon. And it doesn't explain where negative one and negative two went. A balloon explains the photographs that are in the file. It doesn't explain the ones that aren't. And it doesn't explain the last piece of paper. Go back to the card at the front of the file. Under the conclusion there's a cross reference.
26:32"See also: film." And then the number I asked you to hold on to. Seven, three seven four five, three four three. So the Air Force's own index says there was a film kept apart from the paper, under its own number. In June of 1957 a captain wrote that it was in the repository and that releasing it was a matter for higher levels. The next time that number appears is eighteen years later. February twenty-sixth, 1975. Blue Book has been closed for five years. The paper is an ordinary military shipping form. From: the Air Force audiovisual service at Norton Air Force Base, California. To: "Secretary of the Air Force, Washington, D.C." Sent air mail.
27:22Authority: a telephone call from a Captain Kuminecz. And the contents. "Seven rolls of UFO film, as follows." The list runs through Topeka, Kansas, then Okinawa, then Tulsa. And in its first line it says: "Two May fifty-seven, Edwards A.F.B. number one," film seven, three seven four five, three four three. Gordon Cooper said the film from that morning went to Washington and was never seen again. On paper, that is what happened. Eighteen years late. Two details on that form. It says seven rolls. I count six film numbers. And the Edwards roll is marked "number one." The base's report
28:09you'll remember, listed a negative one and a negative two. I can't tell you there was an Edwards number two. I can only tell you what the form says. There is a dull way to read this, and it's probably the right one. In 1975 the Air Force was turning its Blue Book records over to the National Archives and they opened to the public the following year. A box of film going to Washington that winter fits. But follow it to the other end. The National Archives holds a series called Project Blue Book Motion Picture Films. Its online catalog lists twenty items. Great Falls, Montana. Tremonton, Utah. Nothing from Edwards. Nothing from May of 1957.
28:54In fact, none of the six films on that shipping form is on the list. That doesn't mean the film was destroyed. It means it isn't where the others are. The form says a copy of the receipt went to the Air Force's historical research center at Maxwell Air Force Base in Alabama. That is where I would ask next. One footnote, from Swords. He reports that someone in the photo lab cut a short strip from the original and gave it to Bittick who kept it for years, and then burned it, because he was never supposed to have it. So here is that morning, three ways. The file's version. A weather balloon, a speck the size of a match head, and two excitable witnesses. It doesn't explain why the base that launched the balloon ruled it out.
29:41Or where the negatives are. The cameramen's version. A golden disk with a dome, sharp at close range and pictures that were taken away the same day. It doesn't explain forty-one prints of a speck. Or their own first estimate, forty miles. The astronaut's version. Three landing gear on the lake bed, and film held up to an office window. It doesn't explain why the two men he says walked up to it never mentioned a landing not in 1957 and not in 1968. Or why one of them had never heard that he was involved. What is known is short. A roll of film was shot at Edwards that morning. It had a number. In 1975 that number was shipped to Washington.
30:31Today it is not in the catalog where the Blue Book films are kept. What is probable: the thing on the surviving prints is the balloon. What is unknown is what the closer frames showed. And whether anyone at Edwards held them up to the light before they left the base. If Gordon Cooper did, then he saw something the rest of us can't check. If he didn't, then the one part of his story that the paperwork supports is the part about where the film went. He died in October of 2,004. He told it the same way to the end. It went to Washington, "and I don't know whether anyone has ever seen it since." So which was he? A man who looked at those negatives, or a man who heard about them?
31:18Tell me how you read it. James McDonald never saw the pictures either. He said so to Congress, in the last line of case forty-one. "It would be rather interesting to see the prints."