האסטרופיזיקאי אדם פרנק, שבחן את עדויות העב"מים, חושף את מסקנותיו המפתיעות. הוא מציג את הנתונים ומסביר את משמעותם.
עדיין אין תגובות. מה ראיתם? אפשר לכתוב שעה בסרטון (למשל 12:34) כדי שכולם יקפצו לשם.
בשיחה עם דני ג׳ונס, האסטרופיזיקאי אדם פרנק דן בטענות על עב״מים ובשאלה מה אפשר להסיק מהראיות שהוצגו לציבור. הוא מתייחס לסרט התיעודי „עידן החשיפה” ולעדויות של אנשי צבא וממשל, אך מדגיש שטענות על תוכניות סודיות או על הנדסה לאחור אינן תחליף להצגת ראיות שניתן לבדוק. פרנק מזכיר את חקירות חיל האוויר האמריקאי ואת הטענות ההיסטוריות על דוח סודי, שלדבריו איש לא מצא.
פרנק אומר שאינו שולל אפשרות של חיים תבוניים מחוץ לכדור הארץ, אך טוען שהסרטונים והעדויות האישיות שפורסמו אינם מוכיחים ביקור של טכנולוגיה חייזרית. הוא מסביר שזיכרון ותפיסה עלולים להטעות, גם אצל עדים אמינים, ושמדע דורש ראיות שאפשר לבחון באופן עצמאי. כדי להמחיש את הרף הזה, הוא משווה את הטענה על עב״מים לתגליתו של אדם ריס בדבר התפשטותו המואצת של היקום, שנדרשה לעמוד בבחינה קפדנית של מדענים אחרים. פרנק תומך בהמשך חקירה ובצמצום הסטיגמה סביב דיווחים, אך מבדיל בין דיווח על חוויה לבין הוכחה מדעית.
0:00Have you seen that that recent documentary that came out? It was called Age of Disclosure. >> Yeah, I've seen some of it, yeah. >> So, they got like all of the highest level military generals, people in Congress, whistleblowers from government agencies, um different parts of the military to all come out and talk about this real thing that's going on and people going in these skiffs, these secret compartmented uh I don't know what you call them, they're rooms that like nothing can be recorded in and explaining uh what they've been exposed to and like reverse engineered craft that they can't explain. Um And so, if you have all these people that are running this country and in charge of us saying this is real, what
0:46do you make of that? >> Yeah, so this has always been this way. Like going back to this one of the things from my last book, the little book of aliens, I you know, I did did my research on the history of UFOs. And you can find those claims going all the way back to like I think it was 1955, the first study the first Air Force study of you know, UFOs, the first wave of UFO sightings happens in 1947, right? Um and then by the early '50s, so What? >> Was Roswell? >> No, no, no, Roswell came later. Roswell actually >> Uh Roswell was '47, but it was months after the first wave. The first wave was I forgot the guy's name now, where he was flying over the It was a guy pilot flying >> Corso? >> in Washington state. No, it wasn't Corso. >> I know what you're talking about. This is This was Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. >> And he saw like nine things. So, it's actually that's an interesting story in itself cuz it also tells you a lot about
1:31the psychology of things. But let's before I go there, let's Sometimes it's hard to stay on topic, right? Like, "Oh, we're over there. Now we're over there." Um but so the the first um or one of the first uh Air Force studies, I think it was first called Project Saucer and they're like, "Hm, maybe we shouldn't call it that." And then they they changed the name to Project Sign. And the guy who was the head of it >> Grudge. >> Grudge Well, Grudge I think even came later. >> Okay. >> Oh, wait, no, you're right, Grudge. >> Okay. >> So, that was a weird thing, too. >> >> Like, why you Who comes up with these names? >> Project Grudge. >> But the guy who uh the Air Force, you know, major who was in charge of it, he retires like and then he writes a book, first one of these books, claiming, you know, this secret government report that said, and this was interesting, right? Said it was interplanetary, right? Because in those
2:15days, nobody really we didn't really know much about So, oh, yeah, it's interplanetary. Now now, nobody would claim interplanetary cuz we know the the solar system is empty, right? There's no planets in the solar system that can harbor life other than Earth. But anyway, the important thing is he claimed there was I think it was called the report of the situation or something That was the name of this secret report. Nobody's ever found it. Nobody's ever found it, right? People have tried, people, you know, the the black vault people, never found. And that has been sort of the story for every guy, like, you know, that Agent of Disclosure thing kind of pisses me off, right? Yeah, because you know, you get people standing up making claims, but they never show anything. It's like, oh, I you know, I know a guy who knows a guy who knows a guy who saw something, you know, it's like, okay, show me the
3:00saucer. Can't do that, you know? And so this has been So you look at like Sean Kirkpatrick, who was the head of the AA, right? He, you know, from his perspective, it's been this mutual circularity cuz for every of of kind of a, you know, a circular conversation going back to the '50s, there were two kinds of people in the military. The ones who thought the UFO thing was aliens and the ones who thought the UFO thing was ridiculous, right? And there has always been those two groups. For every like with Agent of Disclosure, that's the problem with these kinds of documentaries, they didn't show the armies of army guys and the armies of of intelligence people were like, no, this is crap. So, what cuz there's no actual data. It's always guys who claim they saw something or most of all, they don't claim they saw
3:46it, they claim they know somebody who says they know somebody who saw it. And at what point as a scientist, I'm like, "Come on, man. Show me the saucer." You know what I mean? Like without the saucer, show me a piece of metal that you can distribute to every lab in the country and we'll analyze it. It's never that. It's And you know, we're going now into like the fourth year of these congressional hearings and we still don't have any actual evidence. It's just people talking. And like, can I stand up at a congre- congressional hearing saying, "Hey, you know, I've got a theory of quantum gravity." Which is like that's the most important thing in physics to have a theory of quantum gravity. "But I can't show it to you." You know, should everybody say like, "Hey, Adam Frank invented the, you know, the theory of gravity." Right? It's like, "No, I didn't because I can't show it to you." So, I am not
4:31impressed. I mean, I'm all for the disclosure. Let's If it's true, more hearings, let's actually get to the bottom of it. I'm all for it. But everything I see and the way it gets >> [sighs] >> hyped, >> Um it's frustrating for me. >> frustrating. >> frustrating for me because I I believe that this stuff's real. But all of the public evidence is it's not it's compelling depending on how, you know, generous you want to be to yourself. But you're right. In a in a in a objective scientific setting, you can't definitively say that that any of that any of those videos or any of that testimony proves >> Right. >> Which frustrates me. Frustrates the hell out of me. >> you're right. Your belief I'm cuz like I said, I know lots of people who are in you know, really interested in UFO and UAPs like you, who like yeah, want
5:17evidence. Like would like to know what's going on. And I think that's totally [clears throat] cool, right? But the right, you can't make the mistake from going to there and be saying like there's already proof. Right. You know, there's there's interesting things that are happening. >> there is proof. I don't believe anything we've seen publicly is is proof. I think it exists. And you know, I also think like I it's hard for me to discredit people that are like some of these ex Air Force guys that were in charge of running nuclear bases. You know, these guys are like top of the top of the top when it comes to being psychologically sound individuals, right? They get tested for this all the time because their hand their their job is to protect the the button that launches the nukes, right? >> like them to be kind of stable. That would be a good idea. >> the same guys that are saying they're
6:02seeing this stuff, and there's just too many cases that and then also like the fighter pilots, like the Tic Tac pilots, you know, >> But you know the Tic Tac guy >> the Tic Tac guy got taken away. Like those those Tic Tac pilots, they say they say what they saw and there's no photos of it. The radar came They got confiscated by people right after it happened. So >> So they say. >> We just have these We just have these guys saying this, right? >> Right. And that's like so I've I've interviewed with um >> I think that stuff could have been uh like secret military stuff that we've been testing. I don't know. >> Or or pure state So let me just step back a little bit on this cuz I want people to understand like look, you know, my job, one of my jobs as a scientist, you know, cuz of that grant, is to think about, you know, a alien intelligence, other intelligences. So man, yeah, and do I want them to exist?
6:44Yes. Do I hope that we find them when I'm around? Yes. Is it possible that UFOs are? It's possible. I'm going to be hyper skeptical about it because any in general, any, you know, this is the the Carl famous Carl Sagan quote. Um what is it? Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. And I think that's really true, right? So let me tell you a an interesting story that's sort of related to that thing. Um I once talked to Adam Riess, who is the guy He's a cosmologist and astronomer. And he was the guy who discovered that the universe found the data that the universe was accelerating, right? After the Big Bang, we know that the universe is expanding. Every galaxy is expanding away from every other galaxy. So like, you know, early on in the universe, the universe was set in motion expanding. We
7:31have, you know, absolute data from this. It's, you know, But what he found What we always thought was that okay, you get the Big Bang, everything starts expanding, but the expansion should actually slow down cuz you got all these galaxies, all this matter pulling on all the other matter. So, things should be If you looked If you could look long enough, you could look far enough back and get a good timeline, everything should be slow slowly slowing down. Adam Riess is a graduate student, you know, he's 27 years old and he's doing they they finally have the data to look really far back in time and um and do these measurements. And what he finds is it's accelerating. It's not decelerating. You know, it's not slowing down. >> It's accelerating. >> It's accelerating, right? This is like 1997. And so, you know, he's just like a 27-year-old dude sitting He's up at the mountain, you know, sitting on this
8:16data, right? That is absolutely a Nobel Prize. Like, without a doubt, a Nobel Prize. And I said to him I said, "How did you feel when you, you know, realized what you had?" He said, "And this is like really important." He said, "I was terrified." Because he knew that he was going to have to take these results. You know, this is all his work. He had planned the observations, he had taken the observations, he had done all the mathematical details to analyze the observations. You know, like it's hard to like turn the what you get from the telescope into like, "Oh, the universe is accelerating." >> Yeah. >> And he knew that he was going to have to sit in front of the smartest guys in the world and women and and get grilled. Like, they were going to like these people who know like they know their work down to the, you know, the final You know, it's like it's like going into a ring >> Sure. >> You know, you're a young boxer and
9:01you're going into a ring with five world heavyweight champions, you know? >> so, he was terrified. He like, "Did I make a mistake? Did I" And so, he had an extraordinary claim >> Mhm. >> and he needed to have extraordinary evidence and he was going to have to the gauntlet of fire he was going to have to run through. So, I'm bringing that up to say like, if you have an extraordinary claim, UFOs are aliens, right? You need, first of all, you need evidence of the highest quality, right? Just like if I and my colleagues said, "Oh my god, we found, you know, we're looking at telescope images of, you know, Kepler 34b, some planet." We're like, "Oh my god, there's city lights there, right?" >> Right. I know I'm going to I am going to expect to have my you know, I'm going to get a new one ripped. All my colleagues, even my friends, are going to come after me with knives, as they should, because
9:48if this thing is true, then it is, you know, it'll change the world, >> Mhm. >> So, the problem with like a lot of the UFO data, as you said, is that it's just not up to the standard. You can't make a claim like we are being visited by, you know, alien advanced technology with a bunch of fuzzy blob pictures or personal testimony. Cuz as you said, personal testimony is the worst form of It's the worst form of evidence. There's just nothing you can do with it, right? I mean, so I've talked with some of the pilots, and they're great guys, and a lot of times they're just saying like, hey, could you know, can you talk to me about >> of the guys who saw the Tic Tac stuff, like Fravor or >> Yeah. >> Graves? >> Yeah, Graves. I I was on Graves' podcast. Great guy, you know, and he just is like, this is what I saw, you know, or this is what I remember I saw, cuz you were talking about memory, you know. So, like and there's been all
10:32kinds of studies that show, especially when you get excited, something's happening, that your memory, you know, you just will not So, there's that famous study of like they did They had a bunch of people throwing balls around in a room, right? And they had a bunch of observers, including trained observers, cops and everything, to watch what's going on and report what's happening, right? And while these people are throwing, so it's kind of a complicated thing. People are throwing a white ball. There's some people in in brown shirts, some people in white shirts. Nobody reported the guy in the monkey suit who walked through. They did this again and again. People just missed the guy in the monkey suit who walked slowly through the room. So, it just points to the fact that personal experience >> like that. >> You know, I'm sure people these these pilots are absolutely being honest. It is great that they can report remove the
11:13stigma, you know, remove the stigma, cuz that's what's going to help us figure, you know, people should be able to say what they saw. Um but it's just it's not evidence of the kind that you can, you know, it's just not evidence. Like from scientific point of view, personal testimony is not rigorous evidence. So, that, like you said, what you're saying is like, yeah, you believe it to be true, which is cool. Like, I can have my beliefs, you can have your beliefs, but the whole point of science is to not fool ourselves, not let our beliefs get in the way of what we can actually show to be true. Again, public knowledge, right?" >> If you enjoy watching our show on Spotify or YouTube and you want to be more involved, I encourage you to please come check out our Patreon community. Not only does our Patreon community get every episode you see on YouTube early, fully uncensored, and ad-free, but we're
11:57also doing Patreon-exclusive episodes, as well as live Q&As, and you can get your personal questions answered by our guests every single week. For me, being able to collaborate and communicate back and forth with our Patreon community every week has been huge, and this is my way of saying thank you for the cost of a cup of coffee a month. Now, back to the show.