עד ראייה מתאר אורות כדוריים חריגים שצילם ליד בסיס חיל האוויר לנגלי. הטייס לשעבר ראיין גרייבס מגיב על העדויות.
עדיין אין תגובות. מה ראיתם? אפשר לכתוב שעה בסרטון (למשל 12:34) כדי שכולם יקפצו לשם.
רוס קולת'רט בוחן את הדיווחים על עצמים לא מזוהים ליד בסיס חיל האוויר לנגלי. העד ג'ונתן בטנר מתאר אורות כדוריים שצילם, את מסלולם ואת הבהובם, ולדבריו גם עצם נוסף שנראה שונה. הוא מספר ששוחח עם ה-FBI ומאמין שהתופעות חריגות ודורשות חקירה. התיאור שלו אינו קובע מה היו העצמים.
הטייס לשעבר ריאן גרייבס מדבר על סיכוני בטיחות וביטחון לאומי כשעצמים לא מזוהים מופיעים במרחב האווירי הצבאי, ועל הקושי לדווח על תצפיות. חבר הקונגרס גלן גרותמן מציג הצעת חוק דו-מפלגתית שנועדה להגן על עובדי תעופה המדווחים על תצפיות עב"מים. קולת'רט והמרואיינים דנים גם בצורך בשקיפות ובמידע נוסף על התופעות.
0:04Hello and welcome back to Reality Check. Something is buzzing our military installations and that's official. [clears throat] Today on Reality Check, we're looking at the prevalence of unidentified anomalous phenomena, some might say drones, UAVs, over military facilities. And one of them that we're taking a very close look at is the Langley Air Force Base. You may have seen an article in the War Zone, which is an excellent online publication uh in which um Joe Trevick and uh Tyler Rogueway wrote a piece about so-called drone swarms in December last year. Take
0:53a look at this video. This is a video shot by a local who was standing on the front lawn of his beach house near Langley Air Force Base across the water filming on the evening of December 14th right after sunset. He was watching what was meant to be that night's meteor shower. He says that around 7:15 he began to see red blinking lights from the direction of Virginia Beach coming in high and circling north of Langley Air Force Base heading west and then passing directly over the base heading east and back in the direction they came. It began as one or two coming every few minutes and at its peak he
1:39said I would say there would be upwards of five over the base that would sometimes stop and hover directly over the base. This witness says they were always blinking from white to reddish orange. The blinking wasn't uniform and these weren't planes. The lights were not on the ends of wings or rotors. They were round orbs of light. He's very clear on that point, this witness, which does tend to suggest some questioning to the drones explanation that's given in the war zone periodical. It's a line that um uh has been pushed by many in the defense media for some time that the simplest explanation for what we're seeing here is drones. But are they?
2:28So, we have a late breaking development on this reality check story. The man who shot the videos, Jonathan Butner, has agreed to speak audio only to reality check. He was across the water from Langley Air Force Base on the evening in question on in December and he's now willing to give us his account of what he saw. And the fascinating thing is he's pretty sure what he saw was indeed anomalous, not some kind of commercial drone, helicopter, or other aircraft. Good evening, Jonathan Butner. >> Hello, Russ. >> So, Jonathan, tell me what you saw in
3:13December last year. I I understand we won't say exactly where, but you were in a premises in a residence that was across the water from Langley Air Force Base. Tell me where you were roughly and what you started seeing. >> Uh yes, sir. So, yes, I was uh at a residence on the southern side of the James River at about 700 p.m. on Thursday, December 14th. Uh the sun was just going down for the evening and it was supposed to be a meteor shower that night. So I was I was there, you know, just planning on watching that. Uh you know, directly across from me is Fort Eustus Eustace, then Newport News, and then Langley is off in the distance as
3:59well. Uh, but I began to see right after the sun went down, I began to see these reddish orange blinking lights that that started coming from the southeast of me crossing the James River. Um, they began one, two, three at a at a time kind of, you know, almost in a conveyor belt fashion. They would go north of Langley Air Force Base. Uh it was what it appeared to me which was about I would say 11 or 12 miles away and then head towards uh the west uh past it. But then they would kind of slowly turn and then go straight back over uh where the I
4:47perceived where the base would be. uh kind of confirmed to me that it was Langley when I would sometimes see a a search light that would start flashing from the ground and kind of wave back and forth. Uh uh never really focusing on any of them as they went past, but just kind of like just waving back and forth. The the orbs um I would say looked about cars sized. I mean just from that distance and they kept a very steady pace until they got over that location in which they would start hovering over over the base. >> Now can I ask you this sir? The official explanation at the moment is not really
5:34forthcoming but the word drone has been used i.e. to suggest that perhaps this is some kind of commercial or perhaps military drone of some kind. Is what you saw that night consistent with what you would think of as a drone? >> Well, I think a lot of people seem to think that a drone is like kind of what we're used to seeing, something that you could put in a backpack and control with a remote control. Uh, I mean, these were large and they seem orbshaped. Uh I you know you could say the the word drone uh you know I have no ways of knowing if they were manned or not but these were not not the drones with four blades on on the edges. Uh these were
6:20>> Can I ask you this? Do you think you would have heard obviously you're overwater which does tend to amplify noise. If there were the helicopter propellants, propellers, if if this was like a conventional drone with helicopter propellers, would you have heard it, do you think? >> Um, it, you know, it was quite a distance. I would say it's probably over 10 miles, the ones that were going over the base. Um, but yeah, I've seen a lot of uh helicopters and I've seen a lot of planes from from that vantage point and I know what you know wings look like with the green light on one end and one red on the other or if it was a a Blackhawk with a a tail rotor and also lights around there. You know, the these
7:08orbs were the lights and they would go directly from that reddish orange right to white. It was not like it blinking on and off. And the the blinking was not uniform either. Uh to me it looked like sometimes the orbs would be blinking at different beats as they went over the base. Uh and would sometimes change a as I watched them. It appeared to me. So it was very unusual and not like anything I've ever seen on a on a regular aircraft. >> So that's interesting. So, this isn't the kind of because the thing that made me think that they were probably drones was that you do see these intermittent flashing lights, but they're not lights that are consistent with the kind of lights you'd see that are frequently
7:54following an exact pattern, a frequency on a drone or on a helicopter or on an aircraft. >> Correct. Yes. These did not, in my opinion, did not appear to be like FAA regulated blinking lights on on planes and uh with with that are on the ends of wings. They they seem to to move uniformly. Uh one in one of my videos, you can see where two of the orbs kind of pull apart in distance and one's beating almost like triplet and one's beating in more of a heartbeat path, heartbeat type rhythm. Uh, so you know it it we was very very unusual. >> I think you also mentioned in your earlier conversation with me off camera that there was another type of object
8:41that you saw that night. I don't want to lead you. So tell me what else you saw. >> Yeah. Uh, so I probably saw about 40 of the smaller drones that were at a higher elevation that would >> I would I would say so. Yes. >> Drones. So, so let's let's not use the drone word because that's a very loaded word. You you you saw 40 orb type objects. What color were they? >> Uh they would go from the reddish orange to white light changing from one shade of that light, the reddish orange to white and back and forth. >> Wow. So So this isn't this isn't like a I mean I I noticed the war zone used the terminology drone. This isn't something
9:28that's consistent with something that's the size of a even a commercial drone. A commercial drone is possibly what, a meter across. You're describing something that's the size of a car. It's changing color and the flashing lights on it are changing color and varying intermittently. >> Yes. Yes. And then they would follow the exact path around and then back over uh Langley and sometimes h stopping to hover over the base before they would go back out at that southeasterly direction they came from like towards the Virginia Beach area from where I was. >> And so what was this other object that you saw?
10:13>> Now to me this looked uh very different. It would come from the same direction as the uh I will say smaller but the car size orbs and this it would come down over the northern bank of the James River. So this was probably closer to four miles uh directly past me. It moved uh right westward on on the river past Fort Eustus. And this looked the bottom was a glowing orangish red uh kind of lensshaped uh semic-ircular uh and it appeared to have three white lights uh at the the top of it. Uh and
10:58it moved probably slightly above the tree level very slowly right in front of me. It went past three times. So, this was either three separate vehicles or the same vehicle or or craft uh going circling around three times. Uh, and in my opinion, it kind of looked like it was monitoring or or observing everything that was going on over Langley. >> So, you seem to be describing a mother ship. >> Uh, yes, that's that's I would say that a command command control was something that came to mind while I watched it. Did you see any of the objects coming from that object?
11:43>> No, they it would seem to it seemed to come in separately uh uh and run that different course than the orbs that were coming in and running uh their their pattern. >> And how long did you see these objects for overall? And what time of night was this, John? >> Uh the first one I saw was probably right at 7:15. Uh it peaked I would say around 8:00 PM that that evening and then just like it began it it trickled down to a slow line and the last one I saw was probably right before 900 p.m. which is when I went inside. >> Now as I understand that our good friend Ryan Graves who I'm also interviewing for this program he's helped you get on
12:30to the FBI who are investigating this case. Is that correct? Yes sir. I have spoken with them as well detailing what I saw. >> And was their interest peaked by the fact that you clearly are not describing what I think anyone would describe as a commercial or known military drone. Um, I I would I wouldn't want to speak for them, but they did they were interested and I'm I'm was glad to be able to discuss with them uh you know what what I saw and uh hopefully they'll be able to do you know their due diligence with that. >> Sure. So, have you been approached at all by anybody from the Defense Department, the US Air Force, or perhaps
13:17even from ARO, the uh all domain anomaly resolution office? >> No sir, not at this time. >> Would you be prepared to speak to them and give evidence to them if you were asked? >> Uh, yes. I'm I'm willing to tell my story and uh and and hope in any way I can with any kind of investigation. >> So, John, can I say this? I I actually think I speak for a lot of people when I say it's very easy to get stigmatized and ridiculed for coming forward with sightings of UAPs. I just want to put it on the record. Well done to you for being willing to come forward, for having the courage to speak publicly. Uh and and well done to you also for speaking to the authorities.
14:04>> Thank you. I greatly appreciate that. And I want to say it's been watching people like you and Ryan Graves uh and others who have spoken out which has really been a a reinforcement on this. >> No, thank you. And I I I really appreciate that because we're in this weird situation at the moment where particularly the US Air Force is very reluctant to make any kind of admissions about UAPs. We've had that I think very silly UAP historical report that was done by ARO just in the last few weeks which discounted the possibility that this is anything anomalous. Let me ask you this way. Do you think it's more likely than not that the objects you saw that December
14:50night last year were still an open mystery anomalous? or do you think they are plausibly explainable as some kind of drone technology? >> Uh I in my my opinion is that I I believe they are anomalous and that they do uh deserve to have a thorough investigation and to find out what what they are and what where they're coming from. >> Which all begs the question, why is the Pentagon so determined to put this back in a box here? Are you a resident, a loyal, patriotic American citizen wanting to come forward with evidence. And good on the FBI for taking your evidence. Let's just hope they run with
15:35it properly and give it all the credible investigative analysis that it deserves. >> I agree. It's been frustrating watching uh what has happened to the the Schumer bill, which was held back by a handful of politicians. And it's been frustrating to see that recent report from Arrow and the Pentagon. Uh, you know, I really feel that it is time that we are told the truth to what is going on here. Uh, you I feel, you know, we're sitting on a on a beach and we have a tsunami of truth that could be possibly coming at us. um we're sitting with our lifeguards not not telling us what what is truly happening and and protecting
16:20us. Well, good on you very much, John. And um listen, would you let us know if you are approached by the defense department and obviously if you suffer any harassment at all or any kind of intimidation, we've got your back. So let us know please if you do suffer any kind of intimidation or retribution for coming forward with this account. >> Yes. Yes sir. I definitely will do that and thank you so much for your support. >> Great. Thank you so much John. And um uh just to verify the videos that we're using those are videos that you recorded. You're personally responsible for shooting those videos. >> Yes sir. And how many minutes of video overall
17:05did you record? >> Um, I would estimate maybe around 10 minutes total. And I took a handful of pictures. >> Did you have anybody with you that night? Were there any other corroborative witnesses who can back that you saw what you say you saw? >> Uh, unfortunately, no. It was just me that evening. >> And were there neighbors also looking at this weird phenomena that you were looking at across the water? I I've not heard any of them speak up or or say that any of them happen to see it. >> And uh one other thing I noticed that in the war zone story from Tyler Rogawway and Joseph Trethwick um they talk about the fact that there was a NASA reconnaissance plane that was brought in. Were you there when that plane was
17:50doing its sorties over to the Langley Air Force Base? >> I did not witness that. um during the evening of my what I saw I really did not notice any aircraft uh you know from what I did see in that article I was wondering if that that plane may have been very high to where I wouldn't have been able to really see it but I did not notice any uh military or commercial aircraft uh during the the night of of what I witnessed out outside of the anomalies Please >> and and it was the one evening when you were doing this sighting and recording. >> Yes, sir. >> Yeah. John, thank you so much for speaking to Reality Check and well done
18:36for coming forward and I sincerely hope we get some answers from the FBI on what they find into your sighting. >> Thank you so much. I appreciate everything. Now, I've spoken to this witness and so has our guest today, Ryan Graves, a former FA18 pilot who has actually flown out of Langley Air Force Base and knows well the issue of anomalous objects hovering over the Virginia coast. And what's very interesting is this witness does not believe that these objects, whatever they are, can be easily explained away as commercial drones. He says they didn't behave like a commercial drone. And the one thing
19:23that does puzzle me is if you were some kind of nonhuman intelligence or some kind of stealth technology coming in to get a peak at a US military base, why would you have flashing lights? Now, that's the issue we're going to explore today on Reality Check. And let me now bring in our first guest for today, Ryan Graves. Ryan Graves is a former lieutenant in the US Navy, a former FA18 fighter pilot. He's the co-founder and executive director of Americans for Safe Aerospace, which is essentially a nonprofit dedicated to military and commercial air crew impacted by UAP and
20:08the pursuit of UAP transparency. And you'll know him because in July last year, July 2023, in what was the first public congressional hearing into UAPs in over 50 years, 54 years in fact, Ryan was one of two former US Navy fighter pilots who decided to testify under oath about UAPs being a potential national security and safety of flight issue. Now, his FA18 squadron during 2014 2015 was operating off the coast of Virginia Beach training in a training
20:53area set aside for fighter military aircraft. And they observed and tracked UAPs that had infiltrated military airspace. And as you'll see today, Ryan Graves takes this issue very seriously. Indeed, he doesn't think it's an issue that deserves to be treated with flippency or dismissiveness, which frankly, I suspect is what has characterized much of the attitude from the Pentagon's UAP office, Arrow, the all domain anomaly resolution office up until now. So today we're going to be talking to Ryan Graves about the implications of this latest video from Langley Air Force Base. One of apparently a series of incidents that
21:39occurred throughout December where drone swarms were buzzing one of the most sensitive military facilities on the east coast of the United States. This is a base where they have F22 stealth fighters. It's the forward defense base for the defense of Washington DC in the east coast. What the hell was it in December 2023 that was buzzing one of our most secure fighter bases? So Ryan Graves, welcome to Reality Check and thank you for joining us today. As you know, the war zone periodical online has been reporting that there were drone swarms over Langley Air Force Base throughout December and that in fact at one stage a
22:25very sophisticated aircraft, the WB57 aircraft, which is a a NASA research uh aircraft, was actually flown in to uh apparently get involved in whatever it was that was being surveiled over the base. Do you have any comment, any response to what's been seen allegedly over Langley Air Force Base? >> Well, I think it's incredibly important, Ross, that we pay attention and respect the indications that we're seeing from these drone incursions. Uh it may not seem like that big of a strategic flaw to have these types of uh drone incursions on a base like this, but it does not take that many UAVs, that many drones to cause a serious national security concern as we've seen in the Middle East with attacks on pipelines
23:11and airports. >> Do you think there is any evidence at the moment to conclude definitively that they are commercial drones? Well, I haven't seen enough data on this particular case to be able to say one way or another. I know there are reports that these that the government is reporting these as I believe UAV incursions. I've heard other uh eyewitness testimony stating uh that they've seen things that are a little bit harder to explain, but I think at this point it's too early in the investigation to say either way. >> Why does it matter, Ryan? I mean, obviously you created Americans for safe aerospace out of a genuine concern that these objects, whatever they are, they pose a threat, a possible threat to flight safety and possible threat to national security. Why? What What's your
23:58concern? >> Well, this is this is a perfect example of why we need to be able to identify what's in our airspace and why it's so critically important. Uh we cannot have vehicles that are operating or within our airspace, especially at NMASS as we're seeing here. Otherwise, we're going to have potential serious concerns with general aviation traffic, commercial traffic, and potentially military operations that could be occurring nearby. And let's not forget, these things could be considered weapons themselves. Uh if there are a number of aircraft on the ground at this base, those would make prime targets for a small explosive. >> Well, can you explain to us how significant is Langley Air Force Base? I know it's based near Virginia Beach, across the water from Virginia Beach. It's an area you know well because
24:44you've trained there with your fighter squadrons uh in the the run-ups to preparations for deployments. What is the significance of the Langley Air Force Base? As I understand it, it's got the latest stealth fighter, the F-22. >> Yeah, absolutely. You know, it's not that dissimilar to the type of operations that we are flying in Virginia Beach ourselves in the F-18. Just further to the north, the Navy is conducting their operations with the F-22. And just further north, we're already into DC. So, this is very congested airspace. It's not airspace where you would be expecting a large number of assets to be uncontrolled and unaccounted for. And yet, we've seen repeatedly them to cross into controlled airspace, military bases. And what they're doing, we simply don't know yet.
25:30It's clear from the war zone article that there was a large response to whatever it was that was buzzing Air Force Base Langley. One of the things that characterizes the objects that the witness I've spoken to saw were that these were flashing lights. They were flashing irregularly, but they appeared to have strobing lights on them. Reddish, orange, white lights. That doesn't sound like something that would be trying to stealthily operate over a secret government base, something that's protected by high security like Air Force Base Langley. Is it plausible to you that these would be stealth drones that be that are being flown over a base in a way that's intended to be unobtrusive if they're
26:15operating flashing lights? >> Well, no. I don't think they would be intended to be stealth uh with the way you've just described it. And yes, that's what I've heard as well. We are seeing these objects blinking. uh with white lights. Uh not in the not in the strobe pattern that one would expect due to FAA regulations, but uh patterns that don't seem to meet any uh anything that I'm aware of. Uh additionally, the objects apparently uh have been lit up, the large number of them, while they're operating over the base itself. So, um it did not appear, at least from the information I've received, that these objects were trying to conceal their location or their presence. So this is quite interesting. This is something being operated intelligently
27:00in an overt way over a very sensitive military facility. It's almost like it's sticking its tongue out and saying, "Catch me if you can." Because it doesn't appear that they did recover one of these objects. There's no suggestion from any of the reports that are made in the war zone periodical that there's been any capture or any bringing down of a UAV. And yet we do have anti-UAVV technology that's meant to be able to bring these things down with some kind of electromagnetic beam weapon. >> Well, yeah, we would think that we do have those capabilities, but as I believe it was the oncoming uh Northcom commander said that this was one of the largest priorities or was one of his number one priorities for the first 90 days in his position. And I'm
27:46paraphrasing here, but he he suggested that we simply don't have the national infrastructure to be able to deal with these types of problems. >> And let's put aside the possibility of, if you like, NHI, a non-human intelligence being responsible for these objects for a moment, Ryan. Let's just consider the possibility that they are simply some kind of stealthy drone that's been able to insert itself over a US military facility in a way that has allowed those objects to operate with impunity. They haven't been brought down. That in and of itself is a grave national security concern, isn't it? Even if these are some kind of drone or UAV being operated by either a civilian or potentially unfriendly foreign adversary.
28:31>> Absolutely. It's a full stop situation and we don't have to know where they're from to know it's a problem. The fact that we have unknown assets operating over those types of facilities is a full stop. Uh we don't have to determine whether they're foreign adversary or whether they're UAP. All we know is that they are there and we need to have the resources and attention to be able to deal with it. So let's go to what happened to you. I mean I I remember and all credit to you sir for having the courage and the strength of mind and personality to make that decision to appear before the congress last year. Thousands, millions of people watched on as you gave evidence under oath before a congressional committee expressing the
29:17concern that you felt about the national security and flight safety risks of what you witnessed during 2014 2015 off the Virginia coast. What did you witness? Well, between 2014 and 2015, the squadron that I was in, VFA11 and myself were seeing on near daily basis objects on our radar, on our camera systems, with our eyeballs that we didn't have an explanation for. They performing in ways that our aircraft couldn't. They were out there all day and they would often be so many of them that we couldn't even work in the areas and we'd have to either move or cancel our flights. And to this day, about 8 years later, they are still seeing these objects out there, and we still don't know what they are.
30:02>> So, you're still in touch with pilots who are operating off the Virginia coast in those training areas who are still seeing these objects, >> not just uh off the Virginia Beach coast, but in the Gulf of Mexico as well as the Pacific coast as well. Just recently, I was hearing from a pilot uh who had seen one of these objects uh go right down the right side of his cockpit. Again, another near miss. From his perspective, he thought it was a balloon until his wingman saw a turn and chase after his aircraft. So, we're still having these issues. We still don't know why they can outperform our jets or where they're from. >> Now, what were the kind of anomalies that you and your colleagues witnessed inside your fighter jets when you saw these objects? What kind of things were they doing that defied your
30:48understanding? >> Yeah. So they would, you know, I'll start at the at the slow end and just tell you they'd often be at completely stationary in the sky and very high winds, 120, 150 mph winds. Winds that cause us as pilots in our jets to struggle to stay in the area. And these objects would be perfectly still in the area. And we capture them on multiple sensors and not have an explanation for how they're able to do that. And yet then accelerate to hold at about 350 mph. uh and they would do so for multiple hours and then we'd also see them accelerate to 1.1 or 1.2 Mach over the speed of sound. And while we have vehicles that can do perhaps all three of those different uh regimes, we don't have one platform that can do all three
31:34of those seamlessly in that fashion. Certainly not all day. Obviously, you can't talk about the full extent of the technical abilities of your aircraft, but you've got imaging systems, optical systems on board your jet that allow you to see things even at a great distance. How close did you get to these objects? And did you see anything about those objects that might explain the kind of propulsion system? Were there propellers? Were there rockets? Were there some kind of jet engine that would explain what you were seeing? Well, as naturally inquisitive fighter pilots, we did try to get close to these objects to try to visually see them. Often, it was very hard and we couldn't, even though all our sensors would be telling us where to look, but eventually uh we almost hit one of these objects as
32:19it went right down uh the right side of our wings within about uh 50 ft of the lead aircraft. And you when we saw it, that's when we realized that these were truly something special. There were no uh there were no wings on these aircraft. There were no propellers. There was no exhaust coming out of the back. There was no back to these objects. They appeared spherical. They appeared uh solid and consistent and they would move without any type of energy expenditure as far as we could see with our sensors. >> So, what do you say to the debunkers who consistently claim that what you're seeing was probably some kind of balloon or something that can be prosaically explained? No, >> I think that's just a misunderstanding of how these systems work. It's not just
33:05one sensor or one system that we're using to gather data on what we're seeing out there. It's a number of sensors that are that are collaborating and cooperating across multiple sensors across multiple aircraft and that allows us to get close enough to visually see these with our eyeballs. And so when we can track these objects and then we can sense them on our radar going at very high speeds, these are the same weapon systems or same radar systems that we use to guide our weapons and to keep us alive while we fly. And I have very high confidence that in the data that they're providing us. >> So you're getting, if you like, what I look for as a journalist when I'm interviewing somebody is corroboration. I'm looking for multiple independent objective strands of evidence that allow me to verify that something happened as
33:50described. What you're describing are, if you like, multiple forms of corroboration. There were different sensor systems that were operating that were allowing you to verify that whatever those objects were, they were real. >> Absolutely. And the way our systems are now, all the aircraft are linked together. So when one person seeing something, we're all seeing it. And that just increases our confidence in what what we're reading off our systems. You know, we spend a great portion of our lives becoming experts in these systems. And it's no small thing to do. I would encourage people that are willing to dismiss this at face value to take some time to understand how how important these sensor systems are to us, how much we train to execute on them, and to understand the nuances in these systems
34:36so they can understand why we're so confident in what we see. >> Do you believe that there are pilots that do you believe that all pilots are reporting these sightings either commercial or military? Are we hearing about all of the sightings that are occurring? >> Oh, absolutely not. Um, and I hear from pilots on a almost daily basis that are reporting this, primarily commercial, now that there are standing orders for reporting within the military. Uh, and for every one commercial pilot I talk to, he tells me there's 10 more that just aren't reporting it right now. So I think this is extremely common uh more so than even I've seen the data behind and that we really do deserve it to our aviation professionals to have proper
35:21reporting procedures in place so that they have the proper mechanisms to deal with this safety issue. I >> I completely agree with you. I mean you've got a ridiculous situation where the Pentagon's admitting the phenomenon, whatever it is, is real. And even if it's just UAVs, even if it's a foreign adversaries UAVs, unidentified aerial vehicles of some kind, that's a threat. That's a flight safety issue. Um, it's a ludable thing that the military has mandated that they be reported. What do you think though of the attempt by Dr. Sean Kirkpatrick of Arrow, the Pentagon's UFO UAP reporting office, which seems to be an attempt to play this whole issue down. Well, the reality
36:06is is that you can submit an order and instruction within the military all day to tell the troops to do something. But unless there's buyin at the operational level, at the command level, and there's training to implement it, and there's time spent, and there's feedback given from that reporting, then no, that [clears throat] there really hasn't been reporting implemented. there's just been a shout into the wind unfortunately. And so when we when the all demand anomaly resolution office claims that they're not receiving reports that are relevant to their investigation, I would encourage them to actually do more to encourage reporting through the services so that they have additional data. Uh likewise there is valuable data I believe in the commercial markets as well with the pilots that are what they are seeing on a regular basis. So at least in the military there's been
36:52an expression of will by the leadership albeit somewhat flaccid uh in reality to actually get these things reported. What's the situation in commercial aviation? Is there a requirement imposed on pilots to report these objects? Is there a system, some kind of official system that allows these things to be reported? So there's a fine line in commercial aviation on how the reporting of this needs to be handled. Often what pilots are seeing are lights that are very high altitudes or above the aircraft or perhaps operating around the aircraft but outside of 10 nautical miles. In a lot of these cases, they don't necessarily fit the criteria for a aviation safety report that would go
37:37within certain existing aviation safety reporting systems that are held at NASA and FAA. Sometimes that individual companies such as United or Delta might have their own internal systems that they use to track instances. And so, um, none of these necessarily fit the right methodology for reporting UAP. And it's not encouraged either. And so, one of the things that we've done, uh, we've lo or we've communicated to to folks on Capitol Hill to our representatives to say, "Hey, here's a here's a nononsense way that allows pilots to be able to report something if they see something." And we have to remember a lot of these pilots have been flying for their entire lives. They have 30, 40, 50,000 hours of experience. These are some of our best human sensors that are flying over our
38:22heads every day and every night. We should listen to what they have to say and and take it seriously. >> Yeah. You say that pilots are some of the best human senses that we have, but the debunkers persistently say that you guys get confused, that you don't understand what you're seeing, and that they're capably uh dismissible as prosaic objects, weather balloons. Um, what do you say to those debunkers who consistently tell you that you're not seeing what you think you're seeing? >> Well, I I will not argue that we're not perfect and we're not superhuman. We certainly do make mistakes. Again, that's why it's so important that we have consistent reporting so that we can gather the data, that we can weed out the trash, and that we can really start to see the patterns that emerge. And there's no version of this where not
39:07collecting the data is the right thing to do. >> So, when you testified to Congress in 2023, I think it was July last year, you said that there were 30 witnesses who'd come forward to Americans for safe aerospace. What's the situation now? How many witnesses have you had come forward to your organization since? >> I don't have the exact number on top of my mind, but it it's increased significantly uh multiples since then, especially after the hearing. We've received many more reports and we're still working through them. Uh it was never our intent at Americans for Safe Aerospace to serve as a witness reporting mechanism. Uh but pilots have been going to safe aerospace.org. They've been emailing me directly and we've been receiving port reports nearly
39:53daily. We are working with government stakeholders with scientists and researchers in order to receive these reports and to better understand what they mean from a human factors and a safety perspective. And we're working with government stakeholders that help us understand the ramifications of this from a national security perspective as well. And so this data is being used and it's being used to inform our policies that we're using to educate on Capitol Hill. There's a tendency, and I admit I'm as guilty of this as the next person, there's a tendency to see governments as monolithic organizations that speak with one voice. And I've been guilty, I think, of suggesting that all of government in the US is inclined to dismiss this whole UAP issue. But I've been quite heartened. I've heard from
40:38senior military commanders, people in the air force, people in the Navy who are keen to take a leadership role on this privately telling me that they are taking this UAP issue seriously. Is that your experience as well? >> Absolutely. There are a lot of people both in the military now as well as recent vet veterans and other professionals as well that are reaching out across law enforcement and other agencies that are interested and they want to know more and they want to understand this problem and they want to be a representative for this issue under their uh their current affiliation. And so although we might not be seeing drastic movements on this conversation on a day-by-day or week-by-eek basis, every time that we move the conversation
41:23forward brings new people into the conversation and a lot of those people are within the government and they have some ways to move the conversation forward bit by bit. So it's all very important work. >> There's recently been an FOI. I think John Greenwald's Blackvault website put it up online and there was a pilot off the coast of Florida from the Eglund Air Force Base who claimed that he'd seen an object that was hovering in the sky. Allegedly looked like some kind of acorn, a bit bit like the command module from the Apollo program he described. He drew a picture of it. The video was recorded by his jet. I think his gun camera recorded apparently very good video of the object. The FOI revealed
42:09that the video existed, but were told that that video can't be released because of national security. What do you think of that kind of decision? Is it because is it legitimate to keep that kind of video confidential because it might reveal capabilities of the gun camera vision of the of the jet fighter or do you think that kind of video should be being released? It's a that's a great question. So, I'm not an expert in declassification methodology, but I will say that I have seen in the past the ability to declassify visual uh information by blacking out some of the more um secretive information. So, if this is truly just a regular uh video, um you would think it would be relatively easy to uh black out the information that
42:54would be of concern. However, my understanding is that UAP related information is classified uh via the security classification guidelines that govern UAP. And so although they may classif they may block all the relevant information as it relates to the aircraft or the F-22, right now we would expect them to maintain classification status due to that security classification guideline. So all that to mean is that if they see something they can't explain, they're automatically going to classify it and that's the end of the conversation. >> Yeah. But Ryan, according to the Arrow recently departed boss, Dr. Sean Kirkpatrick, this is all pifil and nonsense anyway. I mean, UAPs appear to
43:39be capable of prosaic explanation. He hasn't seen a shred of evidence, he says, to justify any conclusion that this is nonhuman. Are we being led astray if the military is using security classifications to gag to censor public knowledge of what's really being recorded by the US military? >> Well, I I absolutely believe that that's likely the case as you suggest at the end there. But, you know, ultimately the the public is not going to be satisfied in this conversation until there's some justification to the the dismissal of this conversation that they provided in their recent reports. Um, the the general public is not going to be satisfied by saying the the DoD investigated itself and we we determined
התמלול קוצר כאן. אפשר להמשיך לצפות מהרגע הזה בנגן.